Writing. Thinking. More Writing

Category: Art & Music

Dr. Seuss Stamp

Dr. Seuss and the Question of Artistic Censorship

Like many children of my generation, I love Dr. Seuss and always have, but this post isn’t about what you think it is. You’ve probably heard that Dr. Seuss Enterprises (DSE) has pulled six Dr. Seuss books from publication, and it’s likely you already have an opinion about it. Nothing you read here is likely to change your mind, and that’s fine. This post isn’t about that; it’s about what happens next, the inevitable slide down the slippery slope, and where that leads us.

What Dr. Seuss Enterprises Actually Said

Some background will help avoid confusion. Dr. Seuss Enterprises (DSE) issued the following statement on March 2, 2021 (links and emphasis added), and thus ignited the firestorm of indignation we’re now seeing online:

So, all of these books are now cancelled, if you will, including their adorable covers:

Offensive Dr. Seuss Books

Offensive Dr. Seuss Books – Courtesy of CBC News

And this is of course the right of any rights owner (like DSE) or publisher. I imagine the question in conservative minds is whether left-wing activists are cancelling Dr. Seuss by applying pressure to the publisher in censorial ways?

Is Dr. Seuss Being Censored?

There’s a lot of argument online about whether DSE pulling the books is censorship or not, but all this misses the point. There is government censorship, which we generally oppose as a nominally free society (but which happens all the time), and private sector censorship that we generally support (and which happens all the time). If you take away people’s ability to get information, that’s censorship.

Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information. This may be done on the basis that such material is considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or “inconvenient.” Censorship can be conducted by governments, private institutions, and other controlling bodies. – Wikipedia

All of which is academic. It’s only a legal issue if the government does it by force in contravention of free speech, etc., whereas private companies have every right to publish or not publish just about anything they want. That’s how capitalism works. So, yes, pulling the books is legal, standard, everyday private sector censorship. Forcing DSE to keep allowing the publication of books it doesn’t want to would be compelled speech, which conservatives allegedly object to.

What’s funny to me is that this type of censorship, pulling books from libraries or publication due to public outrage, is Politics 101 for American conservatives. How many books containing sexuality have they successfully pulled from local bookshelves? How many books have they banned for other reasons? I have no idea, but it’s a lot, and you can read more about that here. My point is that conservatives whining about censorship they themselves engage in with enthusiasm is hypocritical, disingenuous, and more than a little humorous. They practically invented this stuff. Welcome to the world you helped create.

What’s Wrong with these Dr. Seuss Books?

Dr. Seuss’ work dates from during and after World War II, and is inevitably going to reflect a different culture and norms than what we see today. That said, there are still parts of these books that are clearly racist and troubling. So, let’s take a look at the specific issues with each book. (Many of the images here are courtesy of the National Post and other sources.)

UPDATE: You can see all of the books in their entirety on the Internet Archive, at least for now, including all offensive pages.

And to Think I Saw it on Mulberry Street (1937)

And to Think That I Saw It on Mulberry Street has a young protagonist fantasizing about a parade including “a Chinaman who eats with sticks,” a “Rajah, with rubies” and two fur-wearing people being pulled by a reindeer. So, yeah, that’s a little racist.

If I Ran the Zoo (1950)

If I Ran the Zoo‘s young male protagonist takes an imaginary hunting trip to Zomba-ma-tant where the Asiatic natives “wear their eyes at a slant.”

And the book also shows Black characters from the African island of Yerka, portrayed as pot-bellied, big-lipped monkey folk:

Dr. Seuss - At the Zoo Offensive Page 1

And something Middle-Easterny going on here:

So, again, not much to debate. These are clearly racist pictures of oppressed cultures.

McElligot’s Pool (1947)

McElligot’s Pool has another young boy, this time dreaming of what he’ll catch while fishing, including “Eskimo Fish from beyond Hudson Bay” with little fur collars. You could argue it’s not the image itself that’s intrinsically offensive–How many little dogs do you see dressed up in little coats on social media?–but it’s coupling with the “Eskimo” caption. Either way, yeah…

On Beyond Zebra! (1955)

This one I’m guessing at based on conjecture online (DSE didn’t specify what was offensive in each book). On Beyond Zebra! adds imaginary new letters to the alphabet, and includes an image of Nazzim of Bazzim riding a camel-like creature called a Spazzim. So…yep. I get it.

Scrambled Eggs Super! (1953)

Scrambled Eggs Super! has a kid bragging about crazy rare eggs, because why not, including one from Mt. Strookoo Cuckoo that he obtains with the assistance of turban-wearing Ali. He gets another egg from the Arctic nation of Fa-Zoal, whose people wear fur and paddle skin-covered boats. Another clear reference to native peoples:

The Cat’s Quizzer (1976)

The Cat’s Quizzer seems to be problematic due to an image of a yellow character in a coolie hat captioned with the question: “How old do you have to be to be a Japanese?” There is also some mockery of pygmies, but I can’t find any examples of the offending imagery online.

UPDATE: I found the following image on the Internet archive, but I see no indication of a cartoon with the text quoted above:

Cats Quizzer Japanese Cartoon

The text here might be at issue (“Do the Japanese eat with pogo sticks or joss sticks?”) but I’m not sure.

But Cat in the Hat was NOT Pulled

Best-selling but still problematic books like The Cat in the Hat, which is allegedly inspired by Black minstrel characters, were not pulled, which tells us something. Namely, that DSE is focused on the bottom line, and that they pulled books for strategic economic reasons. 

Publishing is Struggling & Change is Inevitable

Publishing industry revenues have been flat or falling in real numbers for more than a decade. This is due to many factors, including the influence of Amazon.com and self-publishing, but if you can be sure of one thing it’s that these companies are all about finding ways to make more money while holding onto their legacy assets.

Statistica: Publishing Industry Revenues

Statistica: Publishing Industry Revenues

So you can be sure any given book publisher that pulls a book is doing so, possibly for idealistic reasons, but certainly for financial ones. And this includes rights owners as successful as DSE:

The estate of Theodor Seuss Geisel (better known as Dr. Seuss) nearly doubled its income in 2020, earning an estimated $33 million in a very Grinch-like year. The bigger payday is thanks to a smart new strategy from the team at Dr. Seuss Enterprises, which transformed the beloved children’s author’s 60-plus books into a multimedia universe.  – Forbes

All of which means that publishers and rights owners including DSE will do whatever they can to grow new audiences while holding onto the old. Hence, why they pulled six relatively unpopular Dr. Seuss books while holding onto equally problematic assets like Cat in the Hat. My guess is they might even update and re-release these books in the future, thus gaining the PR value and sales for the retraction followed by secondary sales of the new versions. That’s just good business, if a little cynical.

Publishers Know Controversy Equals Sales

Just look what happened to American Dirt, a novel by a white female author about a Latina woman running to the USA to escape a Mexican drug lord. It has all the immigration porn stereotypes, and BIPOC authors and readers objected to its promotion when it wasn’t written by a LatinX author (See #OwnVoices). Did the publisher pull the book? No, possibly for principled or legal reasons, but also because it knew sales would boom, and they did. American Dirt sold far more books due to the controversy than it would have otherwise.

Publishers Change Book Titles & Content All the Time

One of my favorite examples is the popular and archetypal murder mystery And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie. This book was originally published under the title Ten Little Niggers (sorry), and Ten Little Indians in the US, until they finally stopped finding new ways to be offensive and came up with a completely new title. Was this censorship? Well, I guess if you really wanted a book with an offensive title, but no. It’s just good business and a good if slow awakening to moral reality.

We Should Support Publisher & Owner Changes

Lots of authors write at a time when something arguably bad is acceptable, or when they have too little editorial oversight, or they just get away with stupid stuff. One great example is Stephen King’s It, a fantastic horror novel featuring one of the stupidest and most exploitative scenes you can imagine — children having sex (a gang bang, really) in a sewer to keep the group together. I would love for SK to authorize an update to It without this idiocy.

And the same is true of The Stand‘s portrayals of African Americans (e.g., the infamous ‘black junta’ scene) and its caricature of mental disability. If these changes are not made, the assets that is SK’s legacy will fade faster than it has to, publishers will lose money, and we’re all worse off for it. In other words, if you really want older and “classic” works to survive into the future, you have to admit that (a) some of them are problematic in non-trivial ways and (b) allowing them to change is the only way to save them.

My guess is many books and book series will be pulled or updated in the coming years, not to censor them but to allow the greater body of the authors’ works to survive into the next century. This is a good thing, inevitable, and hardly new. Numerous other books have been pulled or updated based on newer standards of representation, including:

  • And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie for its original titles (see above).
  • Little House on the Prairie by Laura Ingalls Wilder for its depictions of Native Americans, including the line, “The only good Indian is a dead Indian.”
  • Should we Burn Babar? by Herbert R. Kohl, which appears to celebrate colonialism when the MC returns to the jungle to “civilize” other animals.

And so on. All of these changes seem both reasonable and necessary, not censorial.

There’s a Much Bigger Problem for Dr. Seuss

And that is the true goal and motivation of many Seuss-haters, the thing that DSE is fighting against, not the removal or changes to a subset of Dr. Seuss books — it’s the wholesale removal of all Dr. Seuss books from school curricula, etc., due to the problematic nature of some and the history of Theodor Geisel himself.  Because for every antifascist cartoon we like to remember him for…

Theodor Geisel America First Nazi Cartoon

…there is a blatantly racist portrayal of Japanese, Black and other people:

Theodore Geisel Racist Island Cartoon

As a result, there are many who argue with passion that all of Dr. Seuss’ works are tainted and should be removed or at least de-prioritized on school reading lists. And this is the real problem. DSE is trying to appease a group of people with a far larger axe to grind, and this token removal of a few books isn’t going to appease them. The question is whether it should. In other words, do we want a country or world in which entire bodies of work are removed or disparaged due to a (truly) problematic history of the artist and/or a few examples of (legitimate) bigotry? Because that’s the larger question being asked as we squabble over these six books.

Rap Music & Misogyny or Homophobia

Don’t get anxious. I’m not saying anything is or isn’t equivalent to anything else. I’m just asking a question. Let’s look at some troubling rap lyrics just by way of example. This is Dr. Dre rapping in N.W.A.’s “One Less Bitch:”

Yo, I tied her to the bed
I was thinking the worst
But yo, I had to let my n*ggas fuck her first, yeah
Loaded up the forty-fo’, yo
Then I straight smoked the ho

Which you can see and hear here if you like:

My question isn’t about this song or any number of other songs by Black or white artists, whether misogynistic, homophobic, or just violent and ugly. My question is about principles. If our principle as a diverse society is that an artist and his or her entire body of work should be ignored / not purchased / de-listed / censored or whatever the contextual syntax is, based on a subset of that work, then we should apply that consistently.

In other words, if it’s morally right to denigrate all of Theodor Geisel’s work, then we should do this universally and consistently. All of N.W.A.’s music and all of Dr. Dre’s work should be unpublished and removed from distribution by the owner. Any artist who has ever made a substantial negative comment or contribution toward any group, or displayed bigotry of any kind, should have all work taken down and pushed into obscurity, forever. Because that’s the slope we’re sliding down.

So What are our Principles?

I couldn’t care less that DSE had some some problematic Dr. Seuss books unpublished. No, that’s not right; I’m glad they did. I have no problem if they do the same to Cat in the Hat because of it’s problematic history. No one, and especially not children, should be forced or encouraged to read or listen to anything that fills their minds with racism, sexism, misogyny or bigotry generally.

HOWEVER, and that’s in all caps for a reason, I strongly object to the idea that an artist’s entire life work and body of creation should be purged from common distribution because of this. This would be true cancel culture that would make reactionary book-banning conservatives…right. And that’s freakin’ intolerable. Sadly, it also seems like that’s where we’re heading, and this process began long before DSE’s recent announcement.

once-ler-unless

See, I told you this wasn’t about what you thought it was.

Peace.

Modified Terms & Glossary

The following is partial glossary and reference for the Modified science fiction series, starting with Run Lab Rat Run, including some contextual terminology not used in the books themselves. For brevity, names and nicknames of Modified Marathons participants are or will be separately documented. Other resources are referenced at the bottom of this post.

Spoilers? There should be very few spoilers in this glossary, but a careful reading may reveal details of the novel that are not obvious. Note also that updates and edits to the book may mean that the terms shown here do not appear in RLRR or other novels.

A

Alt-Breeder

Refers to any humanoid species created through genetic engineering or other means that is (a) based on human beings and able to reproduce with themselves but (b) not able to breed with natural humans. Alt-breeders are banned internationally, though experiments to create an alternative and genetically incompatible breeder class species continue in secret.

Historical Note: The Crakers in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake are often thought of as archetypal alt-breeders, an innocent and less violent humanoid species created to replace homo sapiens.

Book Note (RLRR): Some believe that Media Conaill’s mother was the subject of unauthorized alt-breeder experiments.

Alvarez v. USNPS

The ACLU sued the US National Park Service on behalf of a natural runner named Pedro Alvarez after his disqualification from the Badwater ultramarathon for being natural and thus thought unable to handle the race’s extreme conditions. The case went all the way to the US Supreme Court, where the ACLU lost in a 5-4 split decision that marked the first time any US court classified the modified as a superior and separate class of human being. Other international cases rapidly followed worldwide.

Android

Any humanoid robot, synthetic or artificial entity with a human or animal appearance or skin. See the modified hierarchy. More.

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Any created rather than naturally originating intelligence, or a near approximation thereof. All artificial intelligence is highly regulated by modified society for its own protection, including specific parameters for AI capacity and compatibility. Self-aware and fully cognitive AI, referred to as General AI, is illegal except under specific conditions. Most synthetics and all Personal Assistants have simulated and throttled AI, meaning that their artificial brains are theoretically incapable of self-awareness or higher-level cognitive functions. See human equivalence restrictions. More.

Anybot / Anymod / Anynat / Anyhom(one)

Variations on “anyone,” these are part of a whole class of linguistic changes to simplify distinctions between groups in modified society (a topic too broad to be covered here). Anybot refers to any non-biological group, anymod to any group of modified, while of course anynat refers to anyone in a group of naturals. The general tension is in referring to groups of people while being clear whether they are modified or not. Usage:

“Anynat who thinks that is crazy.”
“Have you seen anymod who wouldn’t buy that?”

These are related to less common terms such as modmanity, natmanity, etc.

Augmented (Class)

A hybrid class comprising any otherwise natural, breeder or terminal-class person with substantial technical or synthetic optimizations (previous called cyborgs). By convention and common practice, almost all augmented-class modified are considered elevated terminal-class, as their enhancements are not biologically transmissible. By similar if illogical convention, Personal Assistants are not considered sufficient modification to make anyone terminal-class (or everyone would be). See the modified hierarchy.

B

Barkley Marathons

Endurance race created in the late twentieth century to test the limits of (natural) human endurance. Almost never finished by pre-modified runners, the race was largely supplanted by the Modified Marathons once modified racers became the norm. Several aspects of the Marathons’ culture and much of its terminology is based on the original Barkley, despite some complaints that this taints the largely non- or even anti-commercial Barkley itself. For Barkley-specific terminology, go here. See ultramarathons.

Baselines

Entry-level breeder-class genetic modification packages, which are highly regulated under international law. All baseline modifications must be compatible with human reproduction (i.e., cannot be alt-breeder), and open, meaning that all other breeder-class modifications must be compatible with any other baseline modification, regardless of source. See the modified hierarchy.

Bearitos

Specific line of miniaturized bears released by Nomanity as watch-bears and child companions, now commonly used to refer to any reduced-size bear. Nomanity and other companies have entire product lines of miniaturized fauna, from dogs to komodo dragons. See minicorns.

Bioencryption

A genetic and mathematical discipline, bioencryption refers to an attempt to hide genetic or epigenetic information in (a) the publicly visible genome of living humans or (b) elsewhere in their cellular structures as unused DNA. The former part of the field has been fading for years due to the difficulty of hiding anything in plain sight with so little information to work with (as compared to mathematical encryption depending on enormous prime numbers). While it’s entirely possible to store massive amounts of information in unused cellular genetic data, which is often used in genetic courier services, but this has not helped genetics companies protect genetic IP once applied to the actual human genome–and has thus done nothing to prevent GIP issues

Book Note: Media Conaill’s father, Jacob, is one of the most successful scientists in the field.

Biology as a Service (BaaS)

Almost all biological modifications are provided as genetic subscriptions, and automatically deoptimize if not refreshed. Given the similarities between this licensing model and Software as a Service (SaaS), it’s common to refer to genetic modification systems as BaaS (Biology as a Service) or, less frequently, GaaS (Genetics as a Service) or MaaS (Modification as a Service). All terms remain in common circulation and are largely synonymous, though BaaS and GaaS usually exclude augmented-class changes.

The Black

Massive burn area left by uncontrolled arson fires that destroyed the towns of Banning, Beaumont, Cabazon and Cherry Valley during natural riots that reached from Coachella Valley outside Palm Springs to northern Riverside County. The area was declared a National Monument and never rebuilt, and not one of the thousands of bodies in the Black was ever officially recovered or buried. In natural parlance, “black” can refer to any horrible act committed by the modified against naturals, or even the innate character of the modified soul. There are equivalents of The Black in many countries around the world.

Black Flag

Legal term applied to information blacklisted for any group of synthetics or AIs. Having black flag knowledge is considered grounds for immediate termination or destruction of any artificial entity by Synthetic Overwatch. Providing black flag information or even building an intelligence capable of understanding black flag is a felony in all national signatories to various global protocols. All information related to black hole drone levitation is a specially black listed for national security purposes for human beings as well.

Black Hole Drones (BHDs)

Tennis-ball sized hovering drones created by a US military contractor and rapidly adapted for civilian use. Formal name is levitating near-zero albedo spherical drones (LNZASDs), which doesn’t exactly roll off the tongue. They were originally created with radar-invisible shells as stealth monitoring systems. All information on BHD levitation is black flag. See tiny floating entities and tiny floating heads.

Brainjacks (Brainjacking)

Refers to a large set of malicious actions involving everything from illegal use of a Personal Assistant wireless data network to virtual sensory takeovers. Sometimes also refers to nominally beneficial uses including remote parental controls. Brainjacks have been used to induce seizures, plant false memories, encourage suicide, conduct terrorist attacks and more, and remain one of the greatest security concerns in modified society. For this reason, a small but significant group of the modified resist PA implants. Technically, docking is consensual observation-only brainjacking. Because PAs are often specialized AIs, they fall under the regulatory purview of Synthetic Overwatch. See PAPAC.

Breeder (Class)

Lowest major class of genetic modifications in modified society, including all baselines. Breeder-class modifications are highly regulated and must (a) be universally compatible with all other breeder-class modifications and the natural human genome and (b) be technically heritable if not limited by genetic subscriptions. The latter requirement is why most breeder genetic descriptions include concurrent sterilization, in order to protect corporate IP. See augmented and terminal class, and the modified hierarchy.

Chassis

Refers to the core structure of androids and synthetics, as opposed to secondary after-market functions (e.g., synthetic gender) or external aesthetic layers (collectively called “skins” or “coatings“). Increasingly also used to refer to functional aspects of a modified body (e.g., strength, height) vs. aesthetic (e.g., color, age and even external gender). Modified will often speak of upgrading their chassis (e.g., increasing lung capacity) distinctly from modifying their skins (e.g., eye color) in a manner indistinguishable from synthetics. See synthetic envy.

Chrome Demon

Derogatory term for “grays,” the gray-skin-toned children of a small number of parents infected with the genetic contagion that led to the Chrome Wars. Grays have shark-gray skin, silver corneas, gray-white hair and a generally inhuman look that lead many to think of them as aliens or demons. Grays are vanishingly rare in contemporary modified society due to readily available if not required prenatal testing and legalized abortion. They are far more common among naturals, where they are discriminated against much like Blacks and other minorities of earlier times.

Chrome Wars

Race-related international wars of the mid-twenty-first century, caused by genetic contagion that randomized the races of children from infected parents. Covered separately, along with terms such as Chrome, Chrome Demon, Grey, Polychromatic, etc.

Clones

Exact biological replicas of any person or animal. Largely illegal except for brain-dead organ donor banking, though rumored to be popular in some countries as physical backups for rich clientele. And yet there has never officially been a full-consciousness transfer between human and clone. See fodder.

Closed vs. Open Genetic Systems

Some corporate modifications are created to be compatible only with other modifications from the same company, whereas as some companies have no such restrictions. Often the formal vs. factual distinction is moot, as there is no legal requirement to test compatibility, making mixed-brand-modifications (aka modmixing) dangerous or even fatal. One distinction of all baseline and most breeder modifications is that they are must be both open and universally compatible, and thus require far more human testing any other set of modifications.

Combat Models

Modified with commercial military or combat sub-packages of any class (e.g., breeder, terminal or augmented) genetic modifications, and no other substantial non-baseline modifications. This term has no legal meaning, but in the Modified Marathons, there are strict limitations on non-combat modifications allowed in combat competitors.

CRISPR

Scientific discovery that started the genetic engineering revolution of the 2020s. Stands for clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats. Basically, CRISPR provided a low-cost and eventually reliable way to introduce genetic modifications into the DNA of any living thing, leading quickly to the treatment and cure of numerous genetic diseases. More.

Cyborgs

A somewhat archaic and highly derogatory term referring to a hybrid or unification of biology and machines. All augmented-class technical modifications theoretically make people into cyborgs, but it’s not polite to point this out. More.

Deoptimization

Forced or lost (e.g., unsubscribed) genetic modifications or technical modifications, somewhat or completely, socially equivalent to a financial loss or bankruptcy. The only group of human beings lower on the modified hierarchy than compliant naturals are the fully deoptimized (ignoring now illegal fodders). Suicide rates for the fully deoptimized exceed 75%, and in some countries approaches 100%, whereas some degree of short-term deoptimization is normal when the modified change packages and subscriptions–though wealthier modified tend to go on “vacation” during this process in order to hide temporary subabilities. See genetic subscriptions.

Dockers

Refers to consensual or hacked access to a Personal Assistants or similar mechanisms in order to experience what the user experiences. There are two major types of dockers, those who watch what you’re doing, and those who fully experience everything as an immersive virtual world. Note that not all dockers use human hosts, and docking on machines, animals and drones is common in military and research work as well as entertainment. Unauthorized human docking is considered a felony, and is of course rampant. Docking that involves feedback or control of the host is less common but not unheard of, and a perennial security and privacy concern. See brainjacking.

Dysgenics

Deoptimization or reduction in biological abilities, such as removing eyesight or hearing. Fodders, who (which) are only intelligent enough to obey basic commands, are most common example of intentional dysgenics. Opposed to eugenics. More.

Endurance Models

A non-legal designation for people with any genetic modification package that increases physical or intellectual endurance, usually referring to athletes or soldiers.

Epigenetics

Generally refers to heritable traits that don’t depend on specific DNA or RNA coding or changes. More.

Eugenics

Any attempt to breed a “superior” class of human beings, this was a highly derogatory term until the advance of widespread genetic modifications made it synonymous with being modified. All breeder-class germline changes are basically eugenics, to the extent that these changes could be passed on to children if the genetic subscriber wasn’t sterilized. Opposed to dysgenics. More.

Fodders

Banned class of genetic deoptimizations applied to human beings in order to create a relatively stupid, passive, compliant and disposable labor and combat class. Fodders are banned in most countries, which is one reason baseline test subjects are required for genetic research. See dysgenics and the modified hierarchy.

General AI

Usually written as artificial general intelligence, describes any artificial intelligence that has the same open-ended flexibility and cognitive abilities of the human mind (if not more). General AIs are illegal in most jurisdictions, though of course commonly used by governments for cyber warfare and other purposes. Synthetic Overwatch also uses GAIs to monitor synthetic behavior. More.

Genetic Discrimination

Discrimination on the basis of genetic abilities or subabilities. See the modified hierarchy and modifist. More.

Genetic Contagion

Any virus or vector that results in genetic modifications in the infected population. Universally illegal and monitored closely by Genetic Overwatch, one such mysterious virus led to the Chrome Wars. See GIP.

Genetic Jim Crow

Refers collectively to policies, regulations, laws and other structural efforts to disenfranchise naturals, many of which are clearly stated as objectives by the Ascension Party and related think tanks. This includes specific efforts to redefine naturals as sub-human or even non-human for the purposes of political participation and constitutional protections, similar to how the US Constitution originally defined Black slaves as three-fifths human. See Alvarez v. USNPS.

Genetic Overwatch (GO)

International regulatory and enforcement organization overseeing all forms of genetic modification and engineering, sibling to Synthetic Overwatch. Primary focus on prevention of genetic intellectual property (GIP) theft, non-consensual distribution of genetic vectors, and genetic contagions. Formed after the Chrome War virus led to the racial randomization of humanity.

Book Note: At the 29th Modified Marathons, Capt. Jessica Murphy is under contract with Genetic Overwatch to monitor the race due to unusual inclusion of naturals and baselines.

Genoism

Term for genetic discrimination coined by Gattaca director Andrew Niccol around 1997. See modifism.

Genetic IP Vectors or Thieves (GIPs)

GIPs are any ability or person who can transmit or capture genetic information about any other person by touch or other biological or augmented mechanism. Involuntary transmission of a genetic or epigenetic trait from any entity a human being is considered a felony in most jurisdictions. Involuntary sampling or capture of genetic information is generally treated as a theft of intellectual property.

Genetic Modifications

Any modification or change to any genome, whether human or otherwise. Modifications generally fall into two categories, germline (heritable) and somatic (non-heritable), with far greater regulatory concern focused on germline modifications. While the vast majority of genetic subscriptions deal in somatic modifications, most companies still sterilize their customers to prevent accidental germline changes (and to protect their intellectual property). See Genetic Overwatch.

G-mods (Gmods, Gemods, Geemods)

Abbreviation for genetic modifications. Often contrasted with t-mods (technical modifications). All breeder and terminal-class modifications are g-mods, while (almost) all augmented-class modifications are t-mods.

Genetic Subscriptions

In order to generate recurring revenues and protect genetic intellectual property (GIP), almost all proprietary genetic modifications are offered via subscriptions rather than sold as one-time modifications. When subscriptions expire, all changes automatically revert and the customer (person, animal, etc.) is deoptimized or re-set back to their pre-subscription genomic state. This process can be long, painful and even lethal and is thus “not recommended” by most companies for obvious reasons. Changes that cannot be sold as long-term subscriptions (e.g., bone growth) are far, far more expensive.

The Modified Hierarchy

Modified Hierarchy v1

An effort to put all biological and non-biological sentient entities in a clear, ranked structure for social and legal reasons. The simple version is a pyramid with baselines on the bottom, then other breeders, followed by augmented and terminals, and on top the illusory transcendent. See modifism.

Human Equivalence Restricted (HER)

A broad classification for all androids and synthetics that are limited to human-equivalent abilities, intelligence, strength and so on. See Synthetic Overwatch.

Book Note: In Run Lab Rat Run, Coach is a HER synthetic.

Humans Need Not Apply (HNNA)

Slight misnomer meaning natural human beings are not welcome, though sometimes used more precisely by terminal-class modified to refer to anyone beneath them on the modified hierarchy. See Naturals Need Not Apply.

(Sexual) Leveling

A once-popular but always controversial set of breeder-class genetic modifications that were intended to reduce incidences of sexual violence. Modifications included reduced male sex drive, multiple male orgasms, and many other changes (some bizarre and even fatal).

Book Note: These are largely out of fashion and sometimes illegal by the time of Media Conaill’s first Modified Marathons, though Media’s mother was once a subscriber.

The (Synthetic) Mark

There are several national and international standards requiring clearly visible markings on synthetics to identify them as non-human. The most common, the North American standard and Synthetic Overwatch default, is a 360-degree neck ring or necklace. This particular mark type makes synthetics visually obvious and also indicates where the local disable port is on all animal and humanoid synthetics (usually on the back of the neck where you’d find Personal Assistant data ports on modified humans).

Minicorns

Portmanteau of miniature and unicorns, just one of many bad or at least poorly thought out genetic engineering ideas. This one nearly bankrupted TrumaniTech, and helped elevate Dr. Victor Adams to Chairman and CEO. See bearitos.

Historical Note: Full-sized unicorns were first created by Nomanity in the mid twenty-first century, initially true to the pure, peaceful and generally white form of pan-European mythology. While they were at first embraced symbolically by the LGBTQ+ community, Nomanity quickly released a second-generation model of the unicorns intended for military and police service, which rather tarnished the image of unicorns as innocent creatures.

Museum of Biological Optimization (MoBO)

Palm Springs museum of historical genetic modifications that also hosts runners of the Modified Marathons. The race starting line is between the two MoBO towers. MoBO is on the site of the original Palm Springs Art Museum.

Modified / Modification

Any person with a genetic modification other than genetic vaccines. Anyone not modified is referred to as natural. See the modified hierarchy.

Modified Marathons

Ultramarathon and obstacle race on Mt. San Jacinto just outside of Palm Springs, California, starting and finishing at MoBO. Naturals were not allowed in the race until the 29th running when TrumaniTech required their participation in exchange for substantial sponsorship considerations. Much of the naming and structure of the Marathons was inspired by the Barkley Marathons.

Modifism / Modifist

Refers to nominally inappropriate beliefs that the modified are intrinsically superior to naturals (more or less the equivalent of white supremacist). However, given that the modified are physically, mentally and legally superior, it’s rarely used by anyone but naturals or natsymps. See genoism.

Modmixing

The act or practice of mixing modifications from different sources, usually a derogatory term used by corporations to discourage use of (probably incompatible) third-party modifications. However, modmixing is considered trendy among the Terminal class, even when it results in unintended changes, illness or death.

Nagger

Portmanteau of natural and the now archaic n-word, the most common and derisive slur for naturals. Use of the term is considered bigoted and modifist, but is common in private and political speech, and music. Unlike the n-word, nagger has not been claimed for internal use by naturals themselves, for whom it is almost always considered hate speech. See genoism.

Nagger Lover

Any modified in a romantic relationship with a natural, or anyone clearly sympathetic to their cause. While the term miscegenation is rarely applied to natural-modified marriages or interbreeding for obvious historical reasons, there are very few inter-class marriages and most are considered publicity stunts or pity relationships. See modifism and natsymp.

Non-Athletic Regular Person (NARP)

Term in common use on college campuses since the 20th century, generally applied to any non-athlete student or person.

Natsymp

Portmanteau of natural and sympathizer, refers to any modified not overtly hostile to or contemptuous of naturals. See modifism and nagger lover.

Naturals

Plain old human beings without genetic modifications, including people that have nationally or internationally required genetic vaccinations–even though such vaccinations are technically modifications of the original human genome. See the modified hierarchy.

Naturals Need Not Apply (NNNA)

Term that appeared on signs in the middle of the 21st century once modifications were widespread, and then became a stamp of quality on goods produced or manufactured by modified- or machine-only labor. Sometimes abbreviated as 3NA. See Humans Need Not Apply.

Historical Note: See the film Humans Need Not Apply and earlier Irish Need Not Apply for origins of the terminology and historical context.

Nomanity

A TrumaniTech subsidiary, with a focus on animal modifications and genetic contagion. See the Chrome Wars.

Book Note: Nomanity was fauna sponsor of the 29th Modified Marathons. Dr. Kylera Braithwaite (Dr. K) came to TrumaniTech with the acquisition of Nomanity, bringing with her thousands of genetics patents.

PA Gape (PAG)

Tendency of many people to let their mouth hang open when engaged with their Personal Assistants. Considered crass or at least silly in most cultures, PAG is on the DSM-recognized spectrum of reality disengagement disabilities, some of which can be life-threatening.

Personal Assistants (PAs)

Refers to specialized AI and sensory implants most modified use in place of any other form of personal electronics. PAs usually have their own personalities, monitor the health and safety of their host, access all external information sources (including the contemporary equivalent of the internet), facilitate docking, and so on. Not having a PA is considered a sub-ability, at least socially.

Book Note: Media Conaill’s PA in Run Lab Rat Run, Alex, is a third-generation (3G) personal assistant.

PA Privacy, Access and Control (PAPAC)

Collection of laws and regulations related to the use and hacking of Personal Assistants and other personal information.

Personal Assistant Reality Augmentation (PARA)

The ability to use Personal Assistants to create a fully immersive virtual reality that is, for the user, indistinguishable from reality. Due to concerns about hacking, brainjacking, and the risks of prolonged detachment from the physical world, all second generation PAs include some visual indicator of virtual state at all times (often a small red dot somewhere in the visual field). See paragliding.

Paragliding

Being so lost in personal assistant reality augmentation (PARA) that you are unaware of material reality. Common usage includes, “I was just paragliding when I ran into something.” Paragliding is a major cause of death and injury with early personal assistant models, which lacked proximity protection and other controls.

Piss-Poor Protoplasm (PPP)

Twentieth century medical slur applied to sickly or inexplicably weak people, a term commonly used when a natural dies inexplicably or screws up. See definition on Urban Dictionary. Usage:

“That natural died? What Happened?”
“PPP, what else?”

Sex Models

People with sexual genetic modifications including increased sensitivity, greater breast and penis size, multiple orgasms, improved endurance and other more extreme changes such as the flehmen response to improve sensitivity to smell. Not a legal classification and generally derided, sexual packages were often adopted by relatively poor people (desperate naturals) due to being free or very low cost. See leveling and the modified hierarchy.

The Singularity

Theoretical point at which technology runs rampant and radically alters the world, humanity, and everything else. It already transpired a few years before the events in Run Lab Rat Run, but don’t tell anyone. More.

Spider Bots

Specific design of the dominant synthetic protection class, which are themselves managed and monitored by Synthetic Overwatch. Spider bots’ sole purpose is to protect humans from synthetics, androids and all other AI manifestations, though ironically they scare people more than most synthetics.

Subabilities

Refers to abilities absent in people lower on the modified hierarchy, as distinct from disabilities, which are considered natural flaws or genetic diseases. In modified society, every person is sub-able relative to those higher on the hierarchy, and super-able relative to those lower. Calling a sub-able (less modified) person disabled or implying a disability is considered rude, but remains common nonetheless. See modifism.

Synthetic Envy

Refers to a common human desire to be as “perfect” as synthetics, but also confusingly refers to the alleged envy synthetics have for humans (which should be human envy). Hey, it’s English. It’s a mess. See the Vitruvian Synthetic.

Synthetic Overwatch (SO)

Sibling international organization to Genetic Overwatch, Synthetic Overwatch has legal and para-military rights to enforce international synthetic design, behavior, activity and interaction with humans. This includes monitoring personal assistants and preventing brainjacking. See spider bots.

Technical Modifications

Any machine or synthetic augmentation of a biological entity. See augmented.

Terminal (Class)

Strange term that refers to anyone with genetic modifications that aren’t breeder-class. Terminals consider themselves superior to breeders, especially baselines, and most are also augmented if they have the money. See the modified hierarchy.

Tiffany / Tiffanies

Increasingly common term for tiny floating entities, regardless of gender or appearance. As a result, the name Tiffany is increasingly rare, and is more often a derogatory term for shallow or fickle people

Tiny Floating Entities (TFEs)

Refers collectively to any humanoid or animal visual skin on a black hole drone or similar airborne object. In recent years, it’s become common to refer to all hovering entities as Tiffanies (based on TFEs). See tiny floating heads.

Tiny Floating Heads (TFHs)

Virtual holographic layers of human or animal heads projected by many black hole drones to give them more personality, for use as pets, etc. See tiny floating entities.

T-Mods

Abbreviation for technical modifications.

Transhumanism

Highly varied collection of philosophies relating to the improvement of human cognitive and physical abilities, generally also including immortality. Many modified see themselves as either transhuman, or as more truly human than the naturals they regard as obsolete. See modifism and the modified hierarchy. More and fiction about.

TrumaniTech International (TTI)

Fourth largest biotechnology company in the world and parent company of Nomanity. Has the best-selling genetic baseline subscriptions for many years, during which Media Conaill from Run Lab Rat Run was the lead beta test subject, Also the lead sponsor of the 29th Modified Marathons.

Ultramarathon

Technically, any race longer than 26.2 miles, most of which do not include obstacles. The Modified Marathons is an unusual combination of ultra racing, obstacle racing and stage racing. For ultra-running specific terminology, go here.

Genetic Vaccines (UGVs)

Encompasses a broad collection of regional, international and sometimes global genetic vaccines (preventative genetic modifications) that are used to provide immunity to or cures for genetic disorders, and sometimes to “improve” naturals so that they can function in a world dominated by the modified. Often includes temporary or permanent sterilization. Frequently required for employment, travel or government benefits. See eugenics and modifism.

Vitruvian Synthetic

Common image or meme showing synthetics as the idealized person, in place of human beings. Reflective of a common belief that the goal of all modified should be to be as close to synthetic as possible, with transcendence representing the perfect blending of human, AI and machine. See transhuman.

More Information

Etc.

Dcera-Daughter

Critique Lite / 2020 0scars – Short Animated Films

I rarely ever watch the shorts nominated for the Oscars, and sometimes wonder if anyone does. The last time I paid attention to this category, Pixar dominated technically and drove the category toward slick homogeneity, so it’s good to see that 2020’s selections include more international and diverse offerings in a wide variety of media and formats. That said, the quality and artistry also vary widely, making the selections more than trivially uneven. It’s almost as if short animations don’t get multi-million dollar budgets from mainstream studios.

What the 2020 finalists lack in financing, however, they make up for in heart. As the Washington Post put it, “If, as a recent “Saturday Night Live” sketch joked, white male rage is the common denominator in many of this year’s feature nominees, then family — the kind you’re born into and the kind you make — is the hallmark of the shorts.” I can’t disagree. All of the five offerings (Daughter, Hair Love, Kitbull, Memorable and Sister) have a genuine emotional core, though how each touches you will depend greatly on your background.

Which leaves me wondering how you determine what “best” means in this context. Does best mean the most evocative, most technically accomplished, most beautiful, original or best plotted? I imagine it’s a combination of all those, but this year it really shouldn’t matter — Memorable is by far the best in the category — but it’s so white I’m guessing they’ll compensate for the #OscarSoWhite feature film category by picking something more politically appropriate (i.e., Hair Love).

No matter; they’re all delightful in their own way, and I highly recommend watching every one. They’re short after all. My random notes follow in order of my completely uninformed ranking from “most best” (Memorable) to “least best” (Kitbull), but read it in whatever order makes you happy.

All initial descriptions are from the Oscars site.

1. Memorable (France)

“Painter Louis and his wife Michelle are experiencing strange events. Their world seems to be mutating. Slowly, furniture, objects, and people lose their realism. They are “destructuring,” sometimes disintegrating.”

 

This is the single most visually compelling rendition of dementia and it’s emotional impact I’ve ever seen. It’s beautiful, seamless and devastating. Assuming that people realize dementia is a serious disability impacting millions of all races, ethnicity, and genders, this should be the obvious choice for the Oscar. However, the the animators and characters are all white, mostly male (and it’s subtitled and French), so there’s probably not much of a chance (given the political need to balance the lack of diverse contenders in other categories).

Cynicism aside, the imagery and allegory in memorable is just stunning. What I know about stop-motion animation can fit in the period at the end of this sentence, so I have no input on anything other than the result: when Memorable ended, I was gutted but still wanted more. It’s gorgeous.

Where to watch it: Used to be on Vimeo, now theaters only?

2. Dcera (Daughter) (Czech Republic)

“In a hospital room, the Daughter recalls a difficult childhood moment when as a little girl she tried to share her experience with an injured bird with her Father.”

Dcera / Daughter (Daria KASHCHEEVA, 2019) from Miyu Distribution on Vimeo.

Artistically, this story of a strained father-daughter relationship was no worse than second on the list and possible first. The use of dark paper mache and a muted blue pallet are a somber mix, but these thin paper skins are the perfect metaphors for the cracked emotional shells we wear everyday. If not for a few odd breaks in flow, and a painfully obvious ending, this would have come closer to a first-place tie. That said, who cares how it ranks? There’s something insidious and reductive about ranking art. It’s great. Watch it.

Where to watch it: Movie theaters or for rent on Vimeo.

3. Hair Love (USA / 6:48)

“An African-American father learns to do his daughter’s hair for the first time.”

To me Hair Love–the story of a father struggling with his daughter’s big curly hair–is a lot like Black Panther; great not because it was the great per se (though it was excellent), but because it’s the first (?) movie to effectively represent a culture and topic that is important and neglected–the importance, beauty and challenge of black hair in black culture. It’s good. It’s important. But it’s also a bit like Frotasia; dramatic, adorable, sweet, topical and utterly predictable. While it’s delightful to see visual representation of neglected groups, and a dad who (while of course fumbling and incompetent) eventually rises to the occasion, it’s not the “best” anything. Okay, maybe that’s not true; it’s the happiest and most positive of these shorts, and it today’s world, that’s probably worth a lot.

4. Sister (China)

“A man remembers his childhood and growing up with an annoying little sister in 1990s China. How would his life have been if things had gone differently?”

So, spoiler alert, this short is about a sister who doesn’t exist because she was aborted. As China looks back at the consequences of it’s One Child policy, it’s an important and thoughtful work, but the result is mixed at best. There’s some great exploration of what might have been via highly effective narration and interesting visuals, but thematically it’s all a bit twee.

Where to watch it: Movie theaters or for rent on Vimeo.

5. Kitbull (USA)

“A fiercely independent stray kitten and a chained-up pit bull experience friendship for the first time.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZS5cgybKcI

Like Hair, Kitbull is more about message than visual artistry, with the usual trope that if two injured and lonely spirits find each other, magic magically happens, two become one and they live happily ever after. The character play between animals is delightful, especially the cat’s hyperkinetic physicality, but the contextual framing is flat and obvious. Where Sister was twee, Kitbull is trite even if it still leaves you smiling.

Just some random resources and other insights, usually better than mine.

Peace.

Black Panther | Courtesy of TBD

Critique / Black Panther (2018)

White boy reviewing Black Panther! Put your finger on the racial trigger and get ready to fire! Or don’t; totally your call.

I don’t write many reviews because there are already plenty of people generating pablum for movie audiences and it seems narcissistic to spend your time telling other people what to think. So when I do, it’s because I’m trying to figure some things out and writing helps me process what I saw in the theater. Unless it’s Return of the Jedi, in which case it’s because I’m disgusted. #DiePorgsDie

When I wrote about Wonder Woman, it was because some things just seemed odd and I wanted to see if anyone agreed. Jury’s still out on that one. I didn’t want to right a review of Black Panther because of all the online political BS on both sides of the racial divide, and it wasn’t like I was going to change anyone’s mind anyway. But then I saw the movie and came out…perplexed. I had the impression from Rotten Tomatoes that it was either the best movie ever made or a racist anti-white screed that justified Tiki Nazis marching in the streets. Neither perspective is even vaguely correct; it’s not exactly a balanced film, but it’s pretty damn reasonable all things considered.

So, let’s just start with that. It’s a good movie. If you come out of the cinema angry, that’s your baggage; check it at the door and try again. If you come out inspired because it’s the first time you’ve seen such a vast array of powerful, positive black figures, then you were paying attention.

“This movie undid so much of that damage in my childhood mind, I literally wept with relief that: “Yes, world, people with brown skin can be intelligent, people with brown skin can be scientists, they can be strong women warriors, brown people can excel more than colonizers have done in history.” – Indian Country

Even if you forget all about race and history, it’s so much better than most of the other Marvel movies that you should be glad to have gotten your money’s worth. Plus, there are no Infinity Stones. Thank god.

With that in mind, I’m just going to comment on a few good things. Some are big, some are tiny, and some are just general problems with all superhero movies.

What Black Panther Gets Right

It’s a Great Superhero Movie

It’s not The Godfather or Citizen Kane, but in the pantheon of superhero movies, it’s awesome. Black Panther is fun, serious, beautiful, the plot more or less holds together, it’s not just about blowing shit up, there are great actors, real chemistry, genuine charisma, and they kill the white South African mercenary dude–which is always the right answer.

It’s Not Revenge Porn

Don’t get me wrong; there are a couple points where it’s hard to figure out why slightly racist things are necessary, but on the whole it’s just a great movie in an African historical context and lots of cool black characters. While the aforementioned white mercenary is a comical douche, there is also one token white good guy who isn’t killed off ironically or otherwise. Very few “white” movies are as respectful of their token black characters.

There are Lots of Black People

As you may know, Black Panther takes place in Africa. I read reviews complaining about the lack of white people, LGBTQ Hispanics or whatever and I wanted to roll my eyes so hard I’d strip off my vitreous gel sacks. Just kidding; they’re already stripped. Moving on.

It’s Doesn’t Portray Blackness as the Cure for Whiteness

In other words, it doesn’t treat white people as a disease. One on of the things I didn’t like about Wonder Woman was that it went beyond a positive image of powerful woman to an origin story where men are the violent, toxic plague from from which fighty women are the only salvation (it’s part of the origin story, so I get it; it just seemed unnecessary).

Black Panther doesn’t do this. In fact, the antihero Killmonger is “evil” precisely because this worldview motivates him to seek global power over the prior colonial nations. His answer is not the right answer any more than enslavement and colonization itself.  The right answer is balance and social justice, and that’s exactly where the movie ends–with Wakanda coming out of hiding to help address historical injustices and inequity, not violently avenge them. I suppose that’s what I’m supposed to say as a white guy, but it still feels like the right answer morally.

Here is someone who fundamentally disagrees with that comment, at least to the extent that the villain is black:

In 2018, a world home to both the Movement for Black Lives and a president who identifies white supremacists as fine people, we are given a movie about black empowerment where the only redeemed blacks are African nobles. They safeguard virtue and goodness against the threat not of white Americans or Europeans, but a black American man, the most dangerous person in the world. – Boston Review

I can see the author’s point, but I have to wonder if a movie divisive enough to satisfy his needs would have fit in the Marvel Universe at all. This is not the real world. Do we want it to be?

Gender Balance

Men kick ass. Women kick ass. All asses are equally kicked.

Great Black Heroes

Love it. Now we need some Asian- and Native American-led Marvel movies. And more Dead Pool. Not related to anything else; just love Dead Pool.

I Assume Lots of Other Stuff

Would I know if they got something wrong about African culture, costume or whatnot? Nope. It looked beautiful. I hope to see more of it.

What Black Panther Gets Wrong

Wakandan Historical Responsibilities

Kudos to the movie for tackling pan-African responsibility to slaves and oppressed African descendants everywhere. But if this movie timeline is taken seriously, it means Wakandans sat around with superior technology and weapons and just let slavery happen. How is that okay? Struggling with your international responsibilities hundreds of years later is great, but Wakanda literally hid and watched millions of Africans being sold into slavery and did absolutely nothing. One Black Panther king could have single-handedly killed every slaver ever to hit the shores of Africa without exposing Wakanda so…what’s the deal?

Primitive Rights of Ascension

This is not specific to Black Panther, but to any movie that wants to portray a society as advanced while simultaneously glorifying violence as a righteous path to power. A ritual that allows someone to take over the kingdom because they have big pecks and a great right hook is not advanced; it’s primitive, idiotic and exactly as dangerous as shown in the movie. It produces brutal, violent, oppressive, misogynistic leaders who know that violence is answer to every question. Why in the hell would Wakanda choose such a ridiculous right of ascension?

Man-Ape and Monkeyfied Black People

Man-Ape is part of the Wakanda tribal leadership,  and he’s objectively a pretty cool character. I just don’t understand why it’s okay in this genre / universe / context to portray a black person as a man-ape or make freakin monkey noises. Isn’t this kind of analogizing of black people to apes the same crap that got the H&M “Coolest Monkey in the Jungle” hoody pulled? King Kong was racist. Monkey noises are racist. Is it just cool because black people do it to themselves?

Brown Black Face?

I’m just curious about this one. If you’re not native African and are, instead, a mixed-race African American with lighter skin than anyone from central Africa, isn’t being cast in an African in a movie about an isolated African kingdom kind of black facey? Probably not (maybe it shows solidarity); it just seems odd.

Burning All the Heart-Shaped Herbs

Let’s say your entire kingdom depends on a vibranium-infused herb that gives the Black Panther his power. Wouldn’t you want to, I don’t know, keep a back up storage facility somewhere? It’s a freakin’ plant. Grow more of it, hide it, and protect the kingdom. Better yet, spread it across the world and cure all disease. Just don’t let Forest Whitaker have all of it in one little chamber until some asshole burns it.

T’Challa’s Ship Design

Why does every alien / advanced space ship look like a three-blade electric razor? Is there just one design studio in Hollywood? Is it subliminal advertising? I did like the way it also looked like a face mask, but the basic design is barely distinguishable from so many other ships in science fiction movies. Huge issue, right? I know.

T’Challa’s Saved by Falling into a Waterfall

I love you, Killmonger, but have you never seen a movie? I know Sherlock Holmes and The Fugitive are  pretty white, but there was Last of the Mohicans. And The Incredibles. You had to have seen that, right? Aren’t you watching the Olympics?

Women Don’t Bleed

The lead guys do, but not one woman ever shows a wound. Car blows up? They’re fine. Massive battle? They’re fine. Is there vibranium in the makeup? One warrior has her throat cut and dies, but doesn’t bleed. There is something seriously deranged about our need to portray women as powerful warriors while being too squeamish to allow for a broken fingernail.

That’s Not Snow

Can someone please invent fake snow that looks like actual snow? I couldn’t tell if it was salt, shower beads or albino roe. Don’t let your king lie in fish eggs. It’s disrespectful and unhygienic.

What I Worry About

Lot’s of stuff; it’s my thing. But the main one is the potential for unnecessary allegations of cultural appropriation. Let’s say, for instance, that a white boy loves the Black Panther or an Asian girl loves the Dora Milaje and dresses up as them for Halloween. I hope we don’t see angry social media posts about how insensitive they are for wearing new Black Panther costumes when they’re just trying to embrace black heroes. To me it’s no different than a black kid dressing up as Superman, but we do seem to like hating each other these days.

Okay, that’s not really the main thing I’m worried about. The main thing is much bigger and has more to do with the future of American society, but that’s another story. For now, I remain pleasantly surprised, hopeful, and very glad that Black Panther is now part of the Marvel Universe..and mine.

Spoiler Alert! There were spoilers in what you just read.

Peace.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi | Courtesy of TBD

Critique / 50 Things Wrong with Star Wars: Return of the Jedi

A long time ago in a country far, far away, some guy named Tolstoy wrote that, “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way” and the same is true of movies. That’s a bombastic way of saying it’s New Years day and I’m strangely hung over. Well, not strangely, but very, and the effort required to be fair and balanced in this critique of Star Wars: Last Jedi far exceeds my current cerebral capacity. I have given into the dark side and just like Rey (aka New Luke), I’m diving straight into the first black hole I come to.

Let’s start with Porgs.

No, I can’t do that yet. Freaking Porgs.

I love Star Wars. I’m one of those kids who grew up in the 1970s where Star Wars was ubiquitous. There was more Star Wars promotional placement than shag carpeting and marbled mirrors combined. It was as fantastic combination of black-and-white morality and technicolor space laser fights, and no one had excessive body hair. Well-groomed samurai cowboys in space? Sign me up. I’m fully aware of how this nostalgia creates unrealistic expectations, but Star Wars: Last Jedi still disappointed.

After the Star Wars prequels, my standards were so low that the remake of New Hope (Star Wars IV) as The Force Awakens (VII), and the side-story of Rogue One, were both an intense relief. The bar was set at “don’t ruin the franchise forever” and Disney cleared that bar by a fair distance. So now that Disney has brought the franchise back from the brink, it’s time to move forward. It’s time to take all that good will, a fantastic universe and compelling moral themes, and introduce some new characters and new ideas for a new generation of Star Wars fans. You know, do something just a little bit more than remake the Empire Strikes Back with a more diverse cast. That’s not too much to ask, is it?

If I were a Porg, I’d turn to director Rian Johnson with big shiny eyes full of yearning and love. Is it too much to ask, Rian? Is it?

Apparently it is. If you’ve seen Last Jedi, you know it was both wonderful and terrible. Wondrible? Terriful? There were great bits: Leia got a great send off, the cast got even more diverse, salt is pretty and the movie will gross billions, but I don’t care about any of that. I’m here to talk about betrayal.

And I’m talkin’ Lando selling out Han on Bespin kind of betrayal. I’m talking about a movie that has absolutely no respect for the franchise or the fan base. I’m talkin’ about back-stabbing, honorless rebel scum…

Oh, wait, I just had some coffee. It’s bad, but not quite rebel scum bad.

There are of course many (other) blogs that go into the serious thematic issues with Last Jedi, including pretty much everything about the mysterious but not-so-supreme Supreme Leader Snoke, Luke Skywalker’s vacation activities, the absence of a lightsaber battle between Rey and Kylo Ren (Ben Solo), the missing Knights of Ren and so on. It’s like Rian Johnson watched No Country for Old Men and decided that was just the kind of audience disappointment we needed more of.

But those issues are all about failed promises. My focus is more on the movie as high-budget film rather than as another installment in the Star Wars saga. I’ve always hated that once a franchise gets big enough, the writing goes to hell and the audience is expected to just go with it. As much I loved season six of Game of Thrones, for instance, the latest season of the show makes factual and logical errors that would never have been tolerated in the books (e.g., ships cannot fly, armor does not float, etc.). HBO’s Thrones started to lose me where the books never had; George R.R. Martin respected his readers by respecting his characters and the internal consistency of his novels. This is missing in the most recent episodes of GoT just as it’s missing from this installment of Star Wars.

Which brings us back to the Porgs.

Porgs are cute, fat little birds with tiny wings and giant eyes that just want to be loved. They’re so cartoonishly adorable you want to punch them in the face, like Ewoks, but harder. Chewie should have eaten them all: Porgs, Ewoks, Jar Jar and every other other merchandisable abomination. It could have been an epic Muppet buffet (a Porgasbord, if you will), but he doesn’t eat them, not even one. He kills two Porgs and cooks them, but then doesn’t eat them. So wasteful, he is.

Porgs seem cute and harmless, but what they are the living manifestation of disrespect. They are the director’s way of saying cute is better than camp, slapstick is better than wry humor, special effects are better than plot, set design is more important than character, and marketability is more important than substance. It’s Disney’s way of saying you’ll buy anything as long as it comes in a pretty wrapper.

Seem extreme? Well, then let’s take at how the Last Jedi fails as a movie in ways that are completely unnecessary, totally avoidable, and reflect a simple lack of respect for us as intelligent audience members. And then you’ll see why this disrespect poses an existential threat to the franchise itself.

What Last Jedi Gets Wrong

Not so long ago, in a galaxy pretty close to this one, people did some insanely stupid stuff. Here’s just a little of it:

1 / Damien Poe – General Hux Phone Prank

In the opening battle, brave and impulsive fighter pilot Poe Dameron (aka New Han) flies his lone X-Wing fighter directly at a new class of First Order destroyer, the terrifying dreadnought. He needs to stall the General Hux (who isn’t even on the dreadnought) so he can load an attack plan or something, so how does it he do it? With an infantile phone prank.

If the purpose of this scene is to reduce the Star Wars to Spaceballs in less than five minutes and show total disrespect for the franchise, great work. This phone prank is not realistic, it’s not funny, and it sets an infantile tone for a movie that just doesn’t seem comfortable being an actual movie rather than a self-referential farce.

This is dangerous territory. Even the (sometimes) brilliant humorists at Marvel have stumbled when they go from camp to cute. Thor: Ragnorak works because camp is the entire motif of the film, as does Guardians of the Galaxy — but even Marvel fails in Guardians II when Pac Man appears. Being camp and not just cute or moronic is hard, and Disney failed here, miserably. When in doubt, take the joke out. This is a movie, not a stand-up comedy skit.

If this seems like harsh criticism, just think of how Pirates of the Caribbean went from being a brilliant, fresh and funny movie to a complete joke of a franchise. All it takes is bad writing and childish self-indulgence. And an aging lunatic who loves beads.

2 / Dreadnought Destroyer Concept from Star Trek?

As a new type of destroyer, the Dreadnought arrives in the opening with the exact same class name as the equivalent USS Vengeance dreadnought from Star Trek Into Darkness, similar sound effects from Star Trek (2009), and it later turns out to have basically the same light speed tracking ability. I’m not saying Rian Johnson stole ideas from Star Trek, largely because that’s probably libelous and Disney has more lawyers than I do, but they totally stole these ideas from Star Trek. And even if they didn’t, their appearance in movies so close to one another in time and genre should have caused some pause; if you’re going to have a different franchise, maybe make it actually different? You have money, Disney. Buy some new ideas, or at least a different class name. How about the Darthnought?

3 / Dreadnought Design and “Up” in Space

I suppose it’s been said before, meaning it’s been said a billion times, but there is no up in space. This has always been an issue with Star Wars, which is fine, but if you’re going to launch a whole new battle platform, maybe you should put guns on all sides? Or maybe the Resistance can bomb from the sides or bottom where there are fewer guns? Does anyone realize these ships are three-dimensional? Wouldn’t that be daring, if the Resistance used another angle of attack? Mind blowing.

4 / Missing TIE Fighter Escorts

After Poe’s genius-level phone prank, he takes off on run to destroy the surface cannons on the dreadnought. He does this while the entire fleet of destroyers and the dreadnought’s own commander literally wait, watch and make stunned comments. Did they forget they have TIE Fighters? Are they testing their surface defenses (hint: they have none) or checking their Forcebook status? They literally have no fighters on patrol, no protective fighters, make no attempt to launch fighters, and engage in no military action except glaring and swearing. This is, again, a general problem with Star Wars movies (and in fact all movies with over-powered villains that have be defeated), but damn. Maybe have one TIE fighter out there just for show?

5 / Everything about the Bombing Run

There are so many problems with this scene that I could dedicate a blog post to just that, and wouldn’t that be exciting? The bombers are slow as corn growing in the arctic, are apparently only capable of dropping bombs if you click on the blinking red button on a 1969-era remote control, and so on, but there are two far more glaring problems with this part of the movie:

5a / Damien Poe Disobeys a Direct Order

When told by Admiral Leia Organa to call off the bombing run, Commander Poe disregards her direct order. This is a court-martial offense in any military organization. I get that the director wanted to take Poe down a notch (literally, when demoted) and show the dangers of toxic male cowboy behaviors, but this is the kind of thing you get shot for in the military. It’s not cute; it’s basically treason. There was no thematic need to take Poe down this far to make the point. It’s disrespectful to a character who is, presumably, one of the good guys.

5b / Commander Leia Fails to Stop the Bombing Run

So, yes, Leia tells Poe to stop the bombing run, but apparently she doesn’t mean it enough to get on the radio and call off the attack herself. Did all the bombers decide to mutiny? Did all communication fail? Give me a break. No matter how treasonous Poe is, he didn’t take over the entire com network. All Leia had to do was tell the bombers to stop. Problem solved. The fact that all bombers and crews were lost ultimately comes down to Leia’s incompetence, not Poe’s refusal to obey orders. This scene is so dumb that one has to think the only reason the eponymous star wars have gone on this long is that both sides are lead by the mentally disabled (no offense to the mentally disabled). Jar Jar could have done better.

5c / How do Gravity Bombs Even Work in Space?

The bombs released by the Resistance bombers are just chain-fed gravity bombs with no propulsion or guidance. They don’t spread out and they don’t accelerate. They just sort of float “down.” The Dreadnought could escape by just going slightly downwards, or by speed-of-lighting anywhere else, or by very slowly turning. Does the First Order not understand they’re in space? You’d think if you’re going to build a great big ship with a scary name, you’d learn how to escape little floating balls. See comment above about the stupidity of everyone involved in this scene.

5d / BB-8’s Head Fix

One of the threads in this movie is that believability doesn’t matter if there’s a good (or bad) joke in it. BB-8 doesn’t have enough pointy points to fix the circuitry and give Poe back his X-Wing guns? Fine, BB-8, just stick your head in there and connect everything! So funny! Spaceballs again. They’ve gone to plaid.

6 / Ship Gravity and Airlocks

These are not really Last Jedi problems; just as with the concept of “up,” every Star Wars movie has ships with full gravity and amazing air locks on all ships, all the time. Ships may be blown to hell, but the two things they never lose are artificial gravity and atmosphere. I don’t know what what gravity and environmental generation systems are built out of, but they should build all the ships out of it; that shit is indestructible.

7 / Resistance Ships Have to Refuel?

Refuel? You just stole all the Star Trek tech; you didn’t see the never-dying Dilithium Crystals? Or nuclear power? Or, just, never mind. Refueling is stupid.

8 / Resistance Ships Aren’t Faster than Destroyers

As First Order destroyers pursues the rag-tag, fugitive Resistance fleet, we realize they can’t catch them because they’re smaller and faster which is, what? This is space. What part of space are you not getting? In space, propulsion is additive. You want to go faster, you just accelerate more (I’ll just ignore relativistic effects here because Star Wars). Nothing slows you down; there is no air resistance. The only way the smaller ships could be “faster” is if they had a larger thrust-to-mass ratio, and have you seen the engines on those destroyers? This makes no sense.

And if it did make sense, the Resistance ships would pull away from the destroyers. That’s what faster means. But no, the ships stay exactly the same distance away the entire time. This means the Resistance ships are not faster; they are going exactly the same speed and accelerating at exactly the same rate. It’s as if something is keeping them like that to maintain dramatic tension.

8a / Resistance Ship Speed Shouldn’t Matter

In this situation, to catch up to or cut off the Resistance, the First Order could light-speed a few ships in front of the feeling rebel ships, call in reinforcements from other directions, or basically do anything other than press really hard on the gas. Maybe the message here is that fascists can’t think out of the box, because they are the box. Yeah, that’s it…

9 / Why Don’t First Order Guns Work at a Distance?

Do laser weapons dissipate somehow or spread? There is no visual evidence of this. I think you can probably come up with a justification here, but considering that the Star Killer from Awakens could destroy planets in entirely different solar systems, it’s hard to believe energy attenuation is that big a deal. And even if it is, don’t you have any other weapons except wussy pew-pew lasers? Like, say, a torpedo? You could have stolen those from Star Trek too. No one would notice.

10 / Lasers Don’t Bend in Space

That’s a bad way of saying that, barring some external force like gravity, lasers fired from the destroyers shouldn’t arc when they approach the Resistance ships. These rods of deadly light should be perfectly straight. I would be more vehement about this point, but it was hard to tell whether this was an optical illusion or not. If they bent, bad Rian! If they didn’t, bad blogger!

11 / Ship Shields and Related Behavior Make no Damn Sense

Apparently, shields on Resistance ships can prevent cannon and laser fire from bigger ships, but not from smaller ships, or proximity penetration by these smaller ships. I can process that somehow, but instead of using this fact in their attack planning, the First Order pulls back all the TIE fighters (including Kylo Ren, who is laying waste to the rebel fleet) once they are out of range of the destroyers because…why? So they could provide ineffective cover they weren’t providing in the first place? To defend TIE fighters against almost non-existent X-Wings? So the less effective destroyer cannons can do nothing?

They could have ended the whole movie right there with ten more TIE Fighters from even one destroyer. But, no, they want to stare and glare from a distance. Stare Wars: In Space, No One can See You Blink. Nothing about this makes tactical sense. Just like everything in this scene, behavior is manufactured to create a situation that is absurd. The writers were just too lazy to figure out another way to maintain tension between the First Order and Resistance while Finn and Rose jet off to…oh, who cares.

12 / LIGHT SPEED AS A WEAPON

This is in ALL CAPS because it’s a massive issue that can seriously damage the franchise if anybody remembers to use it in the next movies. Which they won’t, but anyway, toward the latter part of the movie, Vice Admiral Holdo takes the helm of the last Resistance ship, turns toward Snoke’s flagship, and light-speeds right through that bastard. BOOM! Massive destruction! Silence in space!

It was great, and I mean that, but it means no other Star Wars battle makes any sense, and never has. X-Wings and TIE fighters have light-speed ability, which means pretty much any small ship or drone can have it too. So every battle can be ended forevermore just by going to light speed while facing the enemy. Destroyers? Death stars? Star Killers? Planets? Borg? All problems with one solution: light speed. Sure, you may need more mass in some cases, but the principal is the same, and that means that with one simple decision Rian Johnson has broken the Star Wars universe. None of it makes any damn sense unless we just believe that everyone is too stupid to use light speed when it matters. You don’t even need Death Stars; just light speed some big rocks and wait. Sure, these are some dumb people, but that dumb? Really?

13 / Tracking at Light Speed

Turns out, Huxley and the First Order can track the Resistance ships at light speed. That means the rebels can’t just warp, I mean light-speed, out of tricky situations. Once all First Order ships track rebel ships in parallel, versus one at a time, the Resistance is pretty much screwed. And maybe that’s fine; maybe the next Star Wars will  introduce a tracker-blocker that magically takes away this power. My real problem with this is that it’s just another copy of the dreadnought abilities from Star Trek. I’m staring to wonder if Disney is buying that franchise too.

14 / Tracking Across the Universe with Blinky Jewelry

Okay, fine, it’s Star Wars. But if you can find anyone anywhere in the universe using a wristwatch-sized tracker, why doesn’t the First Order lace the universe with these things? Cover every rebel ship, inject them into rebel prisoners, etc. It’s just another example of an over-powered technology that would damage the franchise if they even remembered it existed in the next installment.

15 / Caves are Lame

The cave in Empire Strikes Back was lame, and the same cave in this movie is equally pointless even with the existential upgrade. It’s like the writers watched the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows when Harry and Dumbledore find a Horcrux on a dark, rocky island but instead of the Horcrux, Rey finds the Mirror of Erised. I don’t mind things being derivative if there’s a point, but what is the point? That even the dark side can’t show Rey the meaning of her existence? She has to make it for herself (hence, being her own parents)? Great. Boring, but great. It’s a minor issue; I just wish all the brains at Disney could be a little more creative.

16 / Weird Denigration of Men

Every male role in this movie is reduced to a cowboy caricature, dithering incompetent, or is simply irrelevant:

  1. Poe is a rule-disobeying, plot-hatching mutineer rather than the rascally Han who may or may not have shot first (he shot first);
  2. Finn is largely pointless as a character, except as the straight man for Rose. You have a strong black character with no real skills other than “knowing” stuff? Great. Send him off on a quest where he serves no purpose that a good schematic wouldn’t solve. You’re telling me that after destroying thousands of these things, no one kept the plans? Well, it’s a good thing the token black guy has such a good memory;
  3. Kylo Ren is a whiny twit. Darth would have wiped the floor with him. I get it, that’s the point of our new generation of characters: they’re complex. Whatever. He’s boring, even with his shirt off;
  4. General Hux can’t think his way out of a phone prank or successfully kill anything with all his ships. I think he may have died in the end, and I’m not even sure. I know I don’t care;
  5. Emperor Snoke is a joke. There’s a reason it rhymes;
  6. Etc.

I have no problem with a more diverse film. I do have a problem with the pathological need to make men less than women. You can call it justice or vindication, but hat is not diversity or inclusion; it’s just petty and lazy. All of these characters could be more interesting and compelling without taking anything away from female characters.

17 / Hypocrisy with Finn and Holdo Sacrifices

I’m skipping around a bit, but Vice Admiral Holdo saves the last of the Resistance escape ships by light-speeding her way into Snoke’s ship, as noted above. This apparently works because all of the other destroyers were so surprised at her clever maneuver that they forgot to fire their guns. Stare and drool, people, stare and drool. Regardless, it is a heroic act. Hurray for the strong woman!

A little later, Finn decides to do basically the same thing and sacrifice himself to destroy the barricade cannon thing on Crait, which would also have saved many rebels and given them more time to escape. But Finn’s knocked off course by Rose, who then tells him, “That’s how we’re gonna win. Not fighting what we hate, saving what we love.” And then she forcefully kisses him to make her point. Yet another male cowboy protected from his toxic masculinity by a brave woman. Hurray!

Okay, now flip it. Say that when Holdo goes on her light-speed run of self-sacrifice, Poe knocks her off course, causing the death of more rebels, then he tells her about saving what we love, and finishes by forcefully kissing her. Great, right? Not great; there would be a riot. Heroism and sexual assault are only okay when women do it. I think Yoda said it best: “It’s not heoism, young Skywalker, it’s heroism.”

18 / Vice Admiral Holdo Not Telling Anyone Anything

If it’s not clear yet, the key problem with the Last Jedi is that it’s primary plotline — the ongoing pursuit of the Resistance by the First Order — makes no logical sense, and results in a lot of irrational behavior and idiocy that would be otherwise unnecessary. This is also true of Holdo’s communication with her crew about her plan to save them. Basically, she doesn’t tell them anything, and tells Poe to kiss off when he demands information.

So, yes, Poe is out of line and, yes, Holdo has every right to tell Poe to go herd nerfs and get off her bridge; it’s another great take-down of Poe and stupid maleness (Notice how he’s surrounded by women in the scene. It’s subtle). But it serves no purpose; if Holdo was worried about Poe leaking her plans or acting rashly once he knew them, she should have thrown him in the brig. Hiding key information the way she does is just another crappy plot vehicle to justify Poe’s next terrible decision and a whole sub-plot that makes even less sense and nearly gets them all killed.

19 / Everything about Canto Bight Sub-Plot

The entire sub-plot, where team Rose / Finn go off at Poe’s behest to save the Resistance from Holdo’s alleged capitulation, is ridiculously, pointlessly absurd and ultimately counter-productive. It reminds me of Daenerys Targaryen in Game of Thrones; her whole purpose is to show up in Westeros with dragons in Season Six, so you’ve got keep her occupied with random shit for five seasons including dating weird dudes in Qarth. Qarth, for God’s sake. Nobody cares about Qarth.

When you have to do this in a plotline, it means you don’t respect your characters or you’re too lazy to come up with a good sub-plot (or in Martin’s case, you probably just realized your books couldn’t be 1000 pages long). Daenerys eventually melts some slavers with dragon fire. What do Finn & Rose do on Canto Bright? Who cares.

20 / Canto Bright Casino

I don’t know how to describe how bad all this is without yelling, so l’ll just say it sucks at leave it at that. The cantina in Mos Eisley from New Hope introduced us to new aliens, Han Solo, and the dirty underside of Solo’s smuggler world. The casino on Canto Bright introduces us to racial stereotypes (e.g., Asian dealer), cartoon-like aliens, drunken fish, slapstick comedy and an explosion of self-indulgent visual tripe. And this is before the fish thing starts jamming coins in BB-8 because he looks vaguely like nearby slot machines. Is BB-8 hollow and full of holes? That must have worked really well on Jaku. I get campy humor. I like campy humor. That’s not the same as slapstick and outright immaturity. How do they not get this?

Not to mention that this was the first time we’re introduced the the world of arms dealers that feed both sides of the war.  Canto Bright is a missed opportunity to deal with moral ambiguity, the military-industrial complex, tyranny and more. Instead? I wish the Star Killer was still around to take out one more planet.

21 / Finn is Not a Pilot

Wasn’t Finn’s inability to fly the whole reason he partnered with Poe, as in, “I need a pilot”? He never has time to become a pilot, because he’s in a Saran Wrap coma between movies, and yet suddenly he’s piloting everything. He pilots Rose to Canto Bright. He pilots a skimmer on Crait. At least Neo had a magic Matrix machine to teach him stuff; Finn just magically knows. I guess the library force is with him.

22  / Ski Speeders on Crait

These are idiotic vehicles that apparently need a skid to leave pretty marks across a salt landscape and serve no other purpose. The can fly; they don’t need a goddamn skid plate to “stabilize” them. Of course, maybe that’s why the Rebels left them in the first place.

Not Hoth | Courtesy of TBD

Psych! It’s not Hoth because that’s not snow | Courtesy of TBD

23 / Perfect Salt Sea on Crait

Crait’s most dramatic feature is a salt sea created by the perfectly even distribution of a salt layer over a red substrate. It’s beautiful, and of course it looks just like the snowy world of Hoth. This doesn’t really bother me; the salt was pretty and the homage is appreciated, but that’s not how nature works. I take it back; I like the salt sea. Scratch this one.

24 / Only One Way Out of Rebel Stronghold on Crait?

We learn from BB-8’s analysis of the base specs that there is only one way out — through the closed blast doors — and five seconds later they find a way out via (a) the underground tunnels to the trenches (b) the adjacent cliffs for the skimmers and (c) a tunnel exit that is directly behind them and where the crystal doggies lead them. This is beyond idiotic; the base is riddled with exits. When BB-8 read the schematics, he couldn’t identify gaping holes leading to long, walkable tunnels? No one noticed the draft? Usually, military organizations care about that kind of stuff. Ask the Spartans.

25 / Disregard for Resistance Lives

The Resistance’s leadership apparently doesn’t care much about the lives of their troops. Admiral Leia may remember Hoth from her Princess days, and specifically that walkers can’t be taken down by fighter fire — so how is infantry fire or surface cannon going to help? And if you know it can’t help, and you never actually fire a shot anyway, why put your few remaining troops at risk? Are you just making room in the Falcon? I get it; it’s cramped and it smells like Porgs. But come on; don’t kill all the red shirts. I mean, rebel extras.

26 / First Order Military Incompetence

They rule the universe, but they cannot effectively engage in any military conflict, of any kind, ever. Stormtroopers can’t hit anything. Destroyers never fire their guns or, you know, move. TIE Fighters never fight except when it’s too late. Nobody knows how to react under pressure. Did none of them take the Kobayashi Maru exam? Kidding, well mostly. It would help.

To give just one example, when the rebel escape pods are discovered very slowly escaping to Crait, the First Order fires at them…one…at…a…time. They’ve got like ten destroyers and Snoke’s ship, but they just take their time. Pew. Take a sip of space coffee. Pew. Look around.  Pew. Do a jaunty goose step. Pew. Stare and glare.

You’re too stupid to rule the universe.

27 / Rey’s Super Force Power Fight Everything Win Win Win!

I get it. She’s a girl and she’s super force-sensitive, so she can fight anyone with anything without any training. This is a completely unnecessary plot problem with a magical solution: the token training montage. It’s why they exist; to help the audience believe that Rocky can beat Ivan, that Wonder Woman can beat Hades and that X-Men can fight in leather. Everybody’s doing it.

There is no plot or thematic point that justifies the absense of even a minimal training montage to make Rey more believable (or help Finn learn to fly). Luke had one. Kylo Ren had a whole school provided by his uncle, Master Luke Skywalker. Rey has raw power created as a balance to Kylo on the dark side, yes, but not training. And yet she keeps winning. Go girls! You don’t have to work at it; you just have to be young and pretty. Sigh. Maybe there’s some great reveal in the next film that explains it all.

27a / Rey Beating Luke

Good lord. I get the point. The student is now the master; evolution, progress, societal advancement, blah, blah, blah. Occasionally, though, you have to work at it.

28 / Luke Being so Pathetic

Don’t get me wrong; I’ve never been a Luke fan; he was a whiny little kid on Tatooine, and he’s a grumpy old man on Ahch-To island. But damn, dude, didn’t you at least learn to play chess or lift mountains or something useful? You spent decades learning how to milk and fish? You’re why we can’t have nice rebellions.

29 / Fish Wives, I Mean, Nuns

I think I was just annoyed by time the Fish Nuns showed up on Luke’s island. They appear out of nowhere, do nothing but gibber and whine, and I’m pretty sure someone just looked up long-suffering in a pun dictionary to find a group of women to explain how Luke survives on the island, but they are kinda cute. Did they remind anyone else of the women from a Handmaid’s Tail? No? Well, that may be my problem then. Moving on…

30 / Yoda

I love Yoda, but I hate Yoda. No matter how badass he is, he’s still a Muppet with hairy ears and speech impediment who looks different in every movie. Show the guy some respect and let him go to Muppet heaven already. Or buy him a nose hair trimmer and day at the Jedi spa. He needs love.

31 / Jedi Teleconferencing: The Force Will Connect You

In order to have Rey and Kylo interact at a distance, Star Wars invents the Jedi teleconference. Somehow, they find themselves seeing each other across the universe, allowing them to get to know each other in safe, friendly environment. It’s very sweet. We find out later that this is all being done by Snoke to test loyalties and whatnot, which is fine. But even here, with a brand-new feature of the Force, they can’t manage one movie’s worth of consistency. We learn early on that (a) they can only see each other, not their environments and later that (b) Snoke was the one connecting them. So how the heck does Kylo see Luke in one teleconference, and how does it all happen again after Snoke’s dead? Are they just connected now a’la Voldemort and Harry Potter? If so, Rey better keep her clothes on, because…

32 / Apparently, Star Wars is Into Gratuitous Nudity Now

Only Princess Leia gets to be objectified, and only because Jaba is a 1970s blob monster thing. This is a franchise based on getting little kids excited about space and the middle-aged people nostalgic about simpler times. No part of that or any emo / politically correct update requires male or female nudity or undress.

star-trek-into-darkness-alice-eve-underwear

Alice Eve: You can’t copy this. Also, why?

Did you think the gratuitous Alice Eve panty shot from Stark Trek: Into Darkness was something you had to copy as well to attain balance in the gender wars? If so, good job. Steal something from at least one other franchise next time.

Oh, wait, you totally stole the Neo bending-over-backward thing from the Matrix. Forgot about that. Well done.

33  / Crait Planetary Shield

I probably should have put this up with the Crait stuff or First Order incompetence, but this is really just nonsense. The First Order never seems to bomb anything, ever, even when the Rebels are stuck in a cave on Crait, which is when bombs actually work. Why land a bunch of ships that never do anything but get blowed up? Oh, I know, the shields are up, right? Bullshit. In Empire, shield generators were massive and targeted by the Empire. In Rogue One, they was a whole planetary gate that had to be taken out. In this movie, where the rebels are holed up in an abandoned base with antiquated junk and missing tunnels? They somehow have impenetrable shields, like planetary sanitary napkins; nothing gets through. It’s amazing.

34 / What do Stormtroopers Do?

Just asking, but seriously. Anyone?

35 / Phasma’s Chrome Armor
Phasma's Armor

Phasmabulous | Courtesy of TBD

Don’t get me wrong; I dig on Phasma’s getup. It’s stylish, shiny and really stands out from all that Stormtrooper white. But where did it come from? Is that what all the lady fascists are wearing? I didn’t know fascists were so into uniforms as a type of personal expression. Will there be other metallic troopers? Maybe heavy metal? I should read something online about it, but honestly, it’s just because it’s cool, right?

36 / What Happened to the Imperial Droids?

Remember that great imperial droid from Rogue One, K-2SO? Where the Crampus is that thing? You get 100 of those and you can kill off the Resistance while staring and glaring from Canto Bright over afternoon tea. Or are the Stormtroopers some kind of Luddite affirmative action program? Probably a result of the white armor lobby. Seriously, you can’t introduce something that cool and then pretend they never existed. Speaking of which…

37 / What Happened to Tractor Beams?

Just curious. You used to be able to suck stuff out of space, which is occasionally useful and kinda funny. Wanted to make life more challenging, did you? Props.

38 / Supreme Leader Snoke

Okay, so he’s an idiot and he dies easily. Did he not remember what happened to the Emperor, because Vader kills the Emperor pretty much the same way Kylo kills Snoke. Did he think the red ninja guard would save him? I’m not even sure why he’s in the movie. Michael Brown did a better job leading FEMA in New Orleans. Heck of a job, Snokey.

39 / Supreme Leader Snoke’s Monologue

What you need as a villain is a good monologue. Woohoo! You’ve never watched The Incredibles or any movie, ever? Just. Kill. Your. Enemies. It makes you more badass, and you won’t die as often. God, read a book already.

40 / Selective Diversity

It’s barely a point, but why are all the good guys now women and all the bad guys still old white dudes? This isn’t today, right? Or is Snoke meant to be Trump? Also, why was Rose’s sister her sister and not her girlfriend? Embrace the rainbow! Oh wait, she had to kiss Finn, you think. Embrace bisexuality! Now that Kylo is naked and everything is on the table, why not…sorry, getting off track here.

41 / Unsustainable Bad Guys

All the bad guys keep dying. Why? Because they suck. How can you possibly sustain a franchise if you kill all the bad guys and all the ones left are so pathetic? Kylo Ren the Whiny against the Resistance? Seriously? That guy wouldn’t last five minutes in the military. He’d just cry until one of his captains shived him. I’m not even sure what the point of the next movie in this franchise is. To unite Kylo and Rey in a final battle so they can hug it out? To spread Porgs through the universe?

Porgs in Space! You know it’s going to be a thing.

42 / Kylo Ren’s Missing Telekinesis

Whatever.

43 / Luke Sneaking into the Falcon

Didn’t Chewbacca ever watch Aliens? You never leave the loading bay door down; that’s how they get you. Chewie knows better. Maybe he was lightheaded and hangry from not eating the Porgs, but even then he might have noticed when Luke powered up the ship. You know, since he was guarding the MF.

44 / Vice Admiral Holdo’s “Uniform”

She wasn’t wearing one. Instead, Holdo had a nice evening gown…or is that the formal military garb of Vice Admirals? I think she was she dressed for they elegant hour on Canto Bright with her arms-dealer buddies, but maybe her uniform got lost at the cleaners? I don’t know. It’s a pointless distraction. Nice hair, though.

Camo for Canto: Vice Admiral Holdo Stands Out | Courtesy of TBD

Camo for Canto: Vice Admiral Holdo Stands Out | Courtesy of TBD

45 / Millennium Falcon Porg Jokes

No, it’s not funny that Porgs are living the wiring. That’s actually really dangerous and this is a space ship, right? Or are Porgs in Space just going to justify every stupid gimmick they can come up with? They’re like Tribbles with eyes. You have no respect for the Falcon, Rian. None. If this were Star Trek, Admiral Pike would totally throw you off the bridge.

Far more importantly, you remember the artificial gravity thing above? Well, the Falcon has that, and it always points down from the ship’s perspective. Otherwise, the crew would be flopping all over the place every time they turned. So why exactly is the Porg falling against the window? Because it’s funny, right? It’s not funny, it’s cutesy, and it breaks the rules of the Star Wars universe. But I suppose it’ll play well with the kids at Disney World.

46 / Millennium Falcon Leaving Crait

Isn’t Crait still surrounded by destroyers? Don’t they all have lightspeed tracking ability? Wouldn’t they, you know, try to destroy the Falcon or track it since it’s literally the only thing flying on the planet at the end…and the only remaining Resistance ship? Pew!

47 / Jedi Projection: Luke Isn’t Here Right Now

If Jedi can project themselves across the universe and interact in real time as Luke does from his island to Crait, well, why don’t they all do that all the time? It’s way better than flying around in ships. Maybe Luke should have taught Rey that or, well, anything. In a montage. I bet if Luke had said, “Hey, Rey, please stay. I’ll teach you how to project yourself across the universe and right into Kylo’s shirtless boudoir” she’d have stuck around.

48 / Maz Kanata

This little, orange…sorry, just can’t take it.

48a / Maz Kanata has a Jet Pack

Why doesn’t anybody else? Seems pretty cool.

XYZ / And So On…

The list goes on, but I’m not trying to trash the movie; I just don’t get why so many glaringly obvious things are being overlooked or just rubbed in our faces. It feels like Disney is like, hey, they’re dumb, blind fans with too much time and money on their hands. Just pry open their maws and let them eat cake.

Disney has to decide if things can exist without being Disneyfied. Not everything is Bambi and Nemo. Some things are less cute than they are camp, and you have to know the difference. Star Wars worked because it was a morally clear, technically advanced, good-vs-evil, boy-meets-girl, quest that just happened to have two-to-four truly unexpected and charismatic characters and some funny lines. You can’t lean on the characters forever (until CGI replaces them all), so that means you have to rely on the integrity of the franchise.

Lucas nearly killed Star Wars with cute crap and leaden dialog in the prequels. How they made Natalie Portman boring, unattractive, insipid and vacuous is beyond me. And Jar Jar? Damn. Respect the franchise, Disney. It’s yours. You get to do what you want, but it’s not Porgs in Space or Finding Kylo.

Some People Love It (At Least, Politically)

A large number of people really love this movie, but I would argue that what many of them love is not Star Wars but the idea of ripping another franchise away from the white male imperialists of prior generations. In other words, to a great number of people, it doesn’t matter that the movie is good or bad as long as Finn is black and Rose is Asian. It doesn’t matter if the movie is believable as longs as the heroes are female and the villains are male. It doesn’t matter if the film sucks, so long as it complies. This is of course an extreme statement, but there is more than one review accusing critics of the film of racism and sexism.

For instance, Vice writer Brogan Morris says, “If fans are unhappy with Star Wars: The Last Jedi, maybe it’s because Star Wars isn’t what it used to be…the main cast is no longer almost exclusively white and male…” Which is just another way of saying that if you don’t agree that (in this case) Kylo Ren is great, you must be a clueless white dude.

I actually don’t care about either side of this argument; all groups are special interest groups, and all special interest groups have confirmation biases they bring to every experience. What I find troubling is that the logical transition from a white-male dominated world to a, well, not-white-male dominated world is apparently a license to hail wholesale sloth and incompetence as visionary simply because it’s not white-male-cis-gendered sloth and incompetence.

As Angela Watercutter from Wired puts it, disliking Reys’ inexplicable power and skill is not legitimate critique, it is the “…wailing and gnashing of teeth from no-girls-allowed fanboys.” Great. That certainly leaves room for civilized discussion.

To me, a thing should be true to itself regardless of political forces; if Star Wars had an entirely lesbian POC cast, I would still hope it could be a great, internally-consistent movie that didn’t make a joke of itself. But apparently that is not the world we live in. In today’s world, you are only allowed to love Star Wars if you are young and woke, and only allowed to hate it if you’re an old white man. Fortunately, in Star Wars, both sides are so incompetent that the war will never really end.

Some People Love It (Because it’s New)

On the flip side, many people like Last Jedi because it does not have the simple black-and-white morality and one dimensional characterization of Vader’s generation. I agree with this, 100%. What I don’t agree with is that being complex, insersectional, and multi-dimensional means being factually, logically and intellectually ridiculous. I assume that diverse audiences want their minds to be respected, and not just their bodies.

What Last Jedi Gets Right

As I said earlier, there’s a lot of stuff and many other blogs that cover this. There are wonderful homages, great special effects, a good send-off for Leia, a return of the “Force” as an actual force rather than a parasitic presence, no Jar Jar, etc. Rian Johnson also made a valiant effort not to replicate The Empire Strikes Back, even if he did so by just smashing it into another franchise. There is more diversity in the cast, and more complexity in the characters, and so on. There is some really good stuff here and I would recommend seeing the movie. I’ve seen it twice. I can’t hate it that much.

What I’m Really Whining About

There are nearly four hundred million people in the USA (it sounds way bigger when you write it out), and Star Wars probably has a billion fans worldwide. Writers, artists and creatives all all shapes and sizes are ready and excited to contribute. And this is the best we can do with an infinite money and the nearly-endless goodwill of the Star Wars brand? It shouldn’t be; get some damn balls or ovaries, break the damn system, and save this thing from itself.

Otherwise it’s soon going to be the last season of Friends, Bourne without Matt Damon, Thor or Iron Man II, or Pirates of the Caribbean — all of which represent a rapid descent into mediocrity. You have so much money, and even more now that Lucas is paid off. So, maybe, use some of it to save one of the most positive, diverse, unifying franchises in the world today. Please?

Because if you turn this into Cars 3, I’m going to point a lightsaber at Mickey and turn it on with my mind. With my mind. He’ll never see that coming.

In the meantime, Disney, go Porg yourself.

Disney, get the porg out of here! | Mashable

Peace.

Planet of the Apes | Cesar interrupts winter Klan rally, er, military celebration | 20th Century Fox

Critique / War for the Planet of the Apes (2017)

Apparently, Hollywood is tired of our species. The original Planet of the Apes movies were typical of dystopian science fiction of the time; long on moral outrage but fundamentally humanist. The apes were largely despicable caricatures, with sympathetic exceptions, while the humans were long-suffering archetypes of fallen heros struggling for biological redemption.

The new Apes movies have taken a very different view of humanity.  We are arrogant, brutally violent and weak in both mind and body. We are bound for self-destruction if not extinction and, at heart, we know we deserve it. Our sin is so vast and abyssal that denial is the only insanity. Why would we not calmly accept our fate and pass from the earth with some dignity so that a now superior ape species can gracefully take our place?

You’ll have to answer this for yourself. The only humans in this movie are barbaric caricatures, while the apes have become humanity perfected. Well, there’s the mute blond girl, Nova, but we’ll get back to her. War for the Planet of the Apes is like the French noir version of an American classic; there is hope only in the shadows. I’m not sure if it’s meant to be a suicide note left by humanity or just an allegory for American downfall, but I am sure it’s incredibly irritating. Like rubbing your eyes with a power sander. No one should glorify their own self-loathing this much.

Why do I feel thusly? Allow me to enumerate:

1 / The Apes are too Saintly in their Suffering

They are not just an oppressed group, they’re every oppressed group. They’re oppressed African slaves (and please don’t pretend you missed that metaphor); they’re tormented Jews escaping across the desert led by the prophet Cesar-cum-Moses; they’re Native Americans who just want to be left along on their land; they’re every species driven to the edge extinction; they’re every lab animal tortured in a cage; they’re every wrongly convicted prisoner shived in the yard; they’re every sensitive kid who got picked on at school; they are disadvantage personified, nay, apified.

All of which is just a long way of saying that the emotional manipulation is too complete. The saint-like suffering of the apes is like a genetic crucifixion right down to the muscular abs. We get it. They have it rough. Thank God they have Cesar to act as Jesus, Moses and Gabriel all at once.

There is of course nothing intrinsically wrong with this. Movies manipulate us all the time. The question is, to what end. And in this case the end is one in which we feel such empathy and compassion for the apes that we cannot help but despise ourselves.

2 / The Humans are too Pathetic

In contrast to the apes, humans have apparently learned nothing from the plague, wars with the apes or the downfall of human society. We remain brutish and cruel, violent and devoid of even the slightest compassion. Given the choice between sharing the world with the apes and exterminating ourselves, we always choose self-annihilation. Woody Harrelson as Colonel McCullough and lead human character is the cartoonish manifestation of this irrational hatred and selfishness. Would he kill his own son to further his own manic ends? Of course he would. This would be a spoiler if it were not so obvious.

Colonel McCullough in Planet of the Apes

Skinhead Colonel McCullough addresses the troops | 20th Century Fox.

Lest you think that humanity beyond the Colonel is worthy of salvation, the director is careful to make sure almost every human character beyond Nova is violent, idiotic, white and male. We might care if a black man or woman died. But a white man in military gear with the IQ of a lemming? Death is a kindness.

And this is the key message of the movie. Animals are naturally kind and compassionate, resorting to violence only in defense. Humans are naturally hateful scum writhing in their own emotional waste. Given a choice between the two, is there anyone who would not side with the saints of simianity? Of course not. And if there are, they probably voted for Trump anyway

This is the Enemy

This is the Enemy

This may seem like a lot of whining, but movies are now and long have been one of the most effective forms of social propaganda available in a nominally free society, and both Hollywood and politicians know this. During WWII, movies and training videos were produced by the US government for the soul purpose of dehumanizing Japanese soldiers as Asian jungle scum. This of course fit well into the contemporary theme of white supremacy and was not fundamentally different from how Nazis equated Jews to rats and sewer vermin. The purpose was the same; to reduce the enemy to something sub-human and thus deserving of extermination.

It is of course always dangerous to read too much into a fictional movie, let alone a science fiction remake. It is primarily entertainment and that means it’s about money. The problem is that this message sells. We hate ourselves, and we are grateful that Director Matt Reeves has justified the contempt we feel for our species. Now all we have to do is wait for the plague or climate change to deliver us from our undeserved existence. Ahh, inspiration.

4 / No Exploitation Metaphor Remains Unexploited

Those of you who were awake during film theory may remember that King Kong is one of the most blatantly racist movies of all time. It is not subtle. The island natives are gibbering black-faced lunatics. The powerful black ape is taken in chains from his primitive island in the hold of a ship after being seduced by the beauty of the palest of white women. This ape slave cannot speak or understand the world of white men, but he can pound his massive chest and steal white ladies. That is, until he tries to climb the tower of western accomplishment and is taken down by the ingenious inventions of civilized men. It was not beauty that killed the beast, it was white supremacy.

Mad Brute

Not Kong, but you get the idea | Courtesy of TBD

Which is why you always have to be careful when you mix monkeys and white ladies in modern film (unless it’s Diane Fossey). Rather than avoid this troublesome trope, Reeves flips the switch by code-naming Cesar “King Kong” and then pairing him with Nova, the orphaned and mute but still pretty little white girl. Now the ape is eloquent, humane and compassionate while the white girl is speechless and utterly dependent on him for survival. I can’t figure out if Reeves is trying to apologize for the racism of King Kong or is just admitting that we had it wrong all along. Maybe it was really the white man who was always the true animal.

But wait, we’re not done. Not only is the girl now not the downfall of the black ape, but instead she is the bane of humanity itself. As the bearer of yet another disease (apparently one plague was not enough), Typhoid Nova and her little doll can reduce any man to a mute, drooling beast in mere hours. And of course she loves the apes more than the men she lays low. How can she not? The odd thing about this metaphorical shift is that the white woman is preserved as irresistible lure and trap; the only change is which type of man falls in.

Which brings us, oddly, to the lost tribe of simians wandering in the desert. As the film closes, Cesar leads his rag-tag fugitive fleet, I mean a raggedy herd of downtrodden apes, across the desert to the promised land. There is a wonderful shot of apes strung out across the Arizona desert near Monument Valley as they near their destination. Lest you think this a subtle point, here is Wikipedia on the analogous part of Exodus:

“After the Ten Plagues, Moses led the Exodus of the Israelites out of Egypt and across the Red Sea, after which they based themselves at Mount Sinai… After 40 years of wandering in the desert, Moses died within sight of the Promised Land …”

In the movie, we get two plagues, a sea of red sand and Cesar dying within site of the simian mountain refuge and promised land.  Okay, we get it. The apes are downtrodden. They are the hands-down, all-time, award-winning metaphor for victimization. Just give them a safe space already.

5 / No Privilege Remains Unchecked

I’m not even sure this is intentional in the movie, but I’ve been reading a lot lately about social justice and “privilege theory.” Privilege conceptually just means that some groups have unearned advantages over others and social justice thus requires these privileged (generally white, male folk) to “check their privilege” in order to bring out social justice and equality. When you read about this stuff, it tends to become the lens through which you see everything and I’ll readily admit that my confirmation bias is undeniable.

Still, and given that Reeves exists in the middle of the same politically correct environment that regularly promotes privilege checking, I have to assume he’s familiar with the concept. So when you combine the ape victim and human tyrant metaphor with the movie’s second plague, it just feels like he’s turned the masochism up to eleven.

What second plague? Well, it turns out that it’s not enough for the first plague to exterminate most of humanity and concurrently make apes super brainy. No, you need another plague that reduces the remaining humans to  speechless, gibbering…apes. I’m not kidding.

And thus the movie fully checks human privilege generally and white male privilege specifically in the most literal and horrific manner you can conceive (in a PG rated movie). We’re taking your intelligence, your speech, your civility, your sanity and your cute little blonde girl. And if that’s not good enough, then God is going to smite you with a surprise avalanche and take your very existence. Privilege checked and mated, whitey. Suck on that!

More seriously, the self-flagellation here must be what every conservative sees when they hear hand-wringing negativism from every whiny liberal they see in video outtakes from Breitbart. There is a difference between making a point and beating the audience into submission with an allegorical hammer. Even if that hammer is beautifully rendered in RealD 3D CGI.

And so on…

Sometimes we liberals hate ourselves just a little too much. It’s not healthy. Self awareness and critique is fine. Self loathing and destruction is not. Science fiction of the past was almost always a hopeful endeavor. Even the most dystopian vision was meant as cautionary tale rather than prediction or expectation. But Apes sells doom as the darkness we should embrace. Maybe we’re not worth saving as a species. But I don’t need to pay to have a multi-millionaire cram his anti-humanist misery down my throat. I’ve got MSNBC for that.

Just kidding.

Cesar interrupts winter Klan rally, er, military celebration | 20th Century Fox

More seriously, if you enjoy this movie, I have to wonder if you’ve given up on humanity. You might respect Apes’ technical mastery, love the individual characters, laugh at Bad Ape’s worse jokes, and totally miss the how all the gloriously white people at the end are killed by a giant white act of a presumably simian god, but you cannot truly enjoy this movie if you can stand to look at yourself in the mirror.

And that’s just sad, for all of us.

Or I may be reading too much into this. My caramel popcorn was stale.

Peace.

Wonder Woman | Courtesy of Warner Bros

Critique / Wonder Woman (2017)

Wonder Woman is a great movie. I loved it for what it represented for female superhero leads and movie directors, and as entertainment. I also loved finally having proof that DC movies were not all doomed to suck. Batman vs. Superman? Seriously?

But there were a few points in Wonder Woman that drove me crazy. Don’t worry, I don’t care about consistency or origin stories or even logic. It’s a superhero movie. If a cybernetic raccoon can beat the heck out of people in Guardians of the Galaxy, then why not a skinny woman with the power of Superman? It makes as much sense as anything else, and it’s fun to watch.

But there are undeniable social and political messages in this movie beyond the obvious strong female and nominally feminist lead role. And that’s where I’m a bit baffled, or perhaps just frustrated. It just doesn’t seem like it would have been that hard to get a few more things right.

So what did they get wrong? Glad you asked…

Misogyny in the Portrayal of Women

This one may be hard to understand. The whole movie is, after all, about a strong woman clobbering weaker, morally intransigent men and saving the world from the male god Ares. Hope that’s not a spoiler. She wins.

My problem here is with the Prom and Princess trope. Yes, I just made that up, but it’s not that hard to see when you look for it. If you look at male super heroes, they actually look like they can actually hurt something other than your feelings. Like Rocky or Spider-Man, Wonder Woman has the requisite training and self-discovery montage, but at the end Gal Gadot looks exactly as petite as she did to begin with. Is it theoretically possible that she needs no actual muscle to be incredibly powerful because she was made by Zeus to kill Ares (spoiler!)?  Sure, but that’s not the point. The point is the message it sends young women and little girls.

And that message is that the ideal woman is not muscular or physically strong. She does not gain her strength through grit or labor. Instead, the ideal woman is born into the role of Homecoming Queen and Princess combined, and then granted magical powers that make her infinitely powerful while still looking great in a sleeveless evening gown. In this respect, Wonder Woman is like every other alleged female hero served up by Hollywood, where beauty always matters more than strength.

Physical strength has a physical manifestation in women and well as in men. If you look at Jessie Graff, Rhonda Rousey or Serena Williams you’ll see attractive, powerful women who are also physically strong. The have earned that strength with endless hours in the gym, through sweat and injury and pain. They have made themselves worthy of admiration.

The ironic thing about this is that DC is in a better position than any other media group to understand this. The entire (ridiculous) premise of Batman vs. Superman is vaguely sustainable because we all want to believe that a hard working and clever human being (Batman) can beat an obviously stronger and super-power endowed alien (Superman). We want to believe that discipline and effort matter more than magic and genetic gifts. Why is this any less true of woman than of men?

The very simple fact is that all woman can work out to gain strength. All women can train to gain skill. Not all women are born traditionally beautiful or, of course, thin. If Wonder Woman wants to offer a feminist ideal for women, shouldn’t it be for all woman and not merely the naturally privileged?

Instead, Wonder Woman gives us another fairy warrior princess from from an island of warrior princesses.  This makes it just one more in a long line of “strong women” movies cast without actual (physically) strong women in the leading role. Here are some other gems:

  • Angelina Jolie as a bone-thin assassin / spy in Mr. and Mrs. Smith and Salt, ludicrously beating up far stronger men when they can’t even film her running without quickly cutting away.
  • Charlize Theron in Mad Max: Fury Road, where at least she has a cool prosthetic to look both skinny and bad ass.
  • Scarlett Johansson in the Avengers, beating up men who would clearly kill in her a real battle. Of course, she’s super hot, so maybe the men are just too distracted to fight back.

Note that I have no problem casting physically weaker actors and actresses in roles where their powers are more cerebral. Jean Gray and Dr. Xavier could weigh 90-pounds and still kick cerebra with their giant brains. Wolverine? Not so much.

And it’s not like there isn’t a precedent for getting this right, or at least much better. Back in 1997 when they cast GI Jane, Demi Moore was not exactly known for her right hook. But she tool the role seriously enough to at least gain some muscle mass. Instead of fancy filmwork and CGI, you have a believable female special forces heroine. In Aliens, Jenette Goldstein kicked ass as Private Vasquez just like Linda Hamilton did in Terminator 2 as Sarah Connor.

Unfortunately, the true mythology of Wonder Woman is the same as all such films; that female strength is a gift and not earned. That power is in imbued at birth, not garnered by discipline or grit. That beauty matters more than power, or perhaps that beauty is the only power that matters. As long as you’re pretty and your parents were gods, you can do whatever your heart desires. Debutantes unite.

This is a great way to generate more entitled white prom queens,  not female warriors. In the end, and despite all its wonderful traits, Wonder Woman basically body shames woman who actually work out.

Racism in the Portrayal of Black Women

Before getting too deep in to this, remember that I’m a white dude; I am by no means qualified to speak on behalf of black women. But for God’s sake, are you kidding? Even a rational centrist white male like me who is tired of everyone taking everything so damn seriously was immediately offended ridiculous treatment of blackness in this movie.

I know intersectionalism is complex. It wasn’t even in my spellchecker. But Wonder Woman is utterly tone-deaf in the casting of a black woman as Amazon nanny and exceptionally muscular black Amazon warriors on an island of skinny white girls. All of this would have been so easy to avoid.

First, just don’t cast a black nanny serving white women. At least, you know, more than 90% of the time. Problem solved.

Second, don’t represent the black warriors as fundamentally more muscular and brutish than the white women. Here’s how: (1) Look at Robin Wright, Connie Nielsen and Gal Gadot (2) find black actresses who are equally lean and mean. and (3) cast them. It won’t solve all the problems, but it’s a start.

Or, and this is probably the better course, stop casting any Amazon warriors who are skinny little prom queens (See the previous section). If you make them all physically powerful and muscular, they might actually look more comfortable on a battle field than in a corset. Let the war begin.

And while you’re at it, since you’ve thrown out the logical history of the Amazons by including all the races on this nominally Greek island, why not have one of the Amazons be a Nubian half-sister princess who also kicks ass? Then a black woman is in a position of authority and not just in service. DC even has a black Wonder Woman, Nubia, to work with. Just an idea.

Instead, Wonder Woman demeans black woman in the name of feminism. It’s bizarre. Haven’t they seen King Kong or the online body shaming of Serena Williams? How could you possible miss this point?

For more informed commentary:

  • “How Wonder Woman Ignores Black Women” by Cameron Glover on BAZAAR:

    Connecting Black people to brute strength dates back to slave-selling auctions, where a Black person’s value was directly linked to how physically fit they were. Later, this racist rationale justified the assumption that Black people were physically stronger than other races because of genetic differences. Today, Black women athletes like Serena Williams are endlessly ridiculed, their physical strength mocked in anti-Black insults which demean their womanhood.

Misandry in the Portrayal of Men

Nobody’s going to care about this one, but what the heck. If feminism is about equality and/or equality+justice, there is simply no need to maintain the mythological part of this movie that portrays men as intrinsically violent and grotesque–nor to portray woman as inherently better in every way. Amazons can be proud woman warriors and Wonder Woman can be a powerful feminist hero without having to reduce maleness to a caricature of evil.

I realize that in some of the original origin stories, there were no men or males involved in the creation of the Amazons, and certainly not Zeus. But introducing Zeus and Ares as both origin and arch-enemy is just a misandry sandwich. Maybe it was unavoidable given the source material, but it doesn’t have to be this way. Little boys should be able to admire strong female superheroes without having to despise themselves at the same time.

It’s Still a Great Movie

There’s an amazing Nina Simone song, Mississippi Goddam, where she comments on how tiring it is to wait for slow, measured social progress:

But that’s just the trouble
‘Do it slow’
Desegregation
‘Do it slow’
Mass participation
‘Do it slow’
Reunification
‘Do it slow’
Do things gradually
‘Do it slow’
But bring more tragedy
‘Do it slow’
Why don’t you see it
Why don’t you feel it
I don’t know
I don’t know

And she is of course right; being told to wait and be patient while your house burns is great for everyone outside. It makes for a pretty spectacle and the firemen (and women) don’t get hurt, but the house still burns. On the other side, we all know that sudden change to a fragile system can break that system forever. The danger with the latter line of thinking is that it is based in fear.

And Hollywood lives in fear–fear of casting the wrong actor, fear of taking a risk on an unknown writer, fear of offending a demographic or damaging a franchise. Perhaps Wonder Woman is as much progress as we can expect from a Hollywood blockbuster created within a crucible of terrified rich people and mostly men.

So if there is a point to this post, maybe it’s just to provide a little nudge. Wonder Woman is a wonderful movie that proves female characters can drive box office returns and that female directors can be bankable choices. Now that we have that out of the way and the fear is a little less justified, maybe Wonder Woman II can take another step in the right direction.

Just, dear lord, please watch King Kong before then.

Peace.

Orb Little Fluffy Clouds

Orb / Little Fluffy Clouds

When I was driving to Vail a long, long time ago, this song came on as the soundtrack for a VW commercial on the radio. I was instantly obsessed, but no one had any idea what I was talking about.

“You heard of that fluffy cloud song?”

“We don’t sell drugs here.”

“No, really, it’s awesome. There’s this mellow dance track and this girl talks about little fluffy clouds.”

“We. Don’t. Sell. Drugs. Here.”

Yes, this was long before everything was on the internet, and when there were still music stores, but music stores were useless if the random kid you talked to didn’t happen to be into the type of music you were asking about. So I ended up calling VW public relations to find out the band from the commercial, and they told me it was “Orb” and then I went back to the music store and they handed me a massive book to lookup the album and I found it God this was a long time ago.

Anyway, I ended up having to buy a two CD album to the get one song. Cost me like $40 and hours of my life.

Here’s the commercial from TV, by the way. Obviously, this is not what I saw on the radio in my car. You know, in case today’s youth miss that subtle point.

It’s still a great song. But damn, the Internet is awesome.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén