Writing. Thinking. More Writing

Category: Make America Better

10 Ideas to Make America Better #2

Ten more ideas to make America better? Nobody asked, so of course I answered. Here are ten more ideas focused mostly on politics, but also adult drinking and daylight savings time (which are surely related). Some seem like they’d be a slam dunk to implement, some much harder, but all are worth a try.

What do you think we should tackle first?

10 Ideas to Make America Better

1. Make Daylight Savings Permanent or Nuke It

Spring forward! Fall back! It’s like national calisthenics determined to make you less healthy. You know why we have this brilliant institution of annual confusion and electronics abuse? Freakin’ German imperialists:

“The German Empire and Austria-Hungary organized the first nationwide implementation starting on April 30, 1916. Many countries have used it at various times since then, particularly since the 1970s energy crisis.” – Wikipedia

That alone should be grounds for repeal. But it turns out changing the clock also screws with sleep patterns, causes depression, increases accidents and…sucks.

The solution is permanent DST, which of course in the USA is banned by the federal government because…freedom? More on this history of all this here:

As this video suggests, just sent the clocks forward during the spring and leave them there. For freaking ever. It’s not legal for states to do this now, but that should be relatively simple change. It has bipartisan support:

Marco Rubio first introduced the Sunshine Protection Act in 2018, which would move the entire country to permanent, year-round daylight saving time. Rubio has renewed his call multiple times since then, most recently on Tuesday: “The call to end the antiquated practice of clock changing is gaining momentum throughout the nation,” he said. – NPR

How? Pass the Sunshine Protection Act, set your clocks, and leave ’em. Forever. That’s it. Sounds nice, doesn’t it? Write your legislators. Call them. They’re lonely and want to hear from you. Sign the petition. Do something!

2. Get Rid of Term Limits Except for Executives

Okay, this will be controversial and probably sound counter-intuitive, but term limits are just a terrible idea (for anything except executives, and maybe even there). Does anyone really think term limits taking effect in California starting in 1990 made California better? It did not improve politics, partisanship, policy or much of anything positive.

What term limits did in California is what they always do; ensure that ignorant, inexperienced politicians have to rely on special interests to tell them what to do on complex topics they barely understand and don’t have time to learn while figuring out what office they can run for after being termed out. Term limits empower money and lobbyists over people, period. And that’s why conservative think-tanks like ALEC love them. They want more power in the hands of corporations, and less in yours.

But what’s worse is that they are objectively unconstitutional and a gross violation of our democracy. Why? Well, think about it. People, soldiers, advocates and others have literally fought and died to give you a right to vote. And because we’re too lazy to do our job voting, we want to surrender that right back to the government so it can then tell us we can’t vote for the candidate we want.

This is the very definition of fascism, limiting votes to only those the government approves of. Term limits are a betrayal of democracy, period. If you really want to limit the power of incumbents, I’ve suggested a different approach called incumbent handicapping that increases  the votes required to hold office with each subsequent term, but even without that, term limits need to go.

But term limits could also tend to promote longer tenure than necessary, as well as perverse incentives for self-dealing in a lame-duck term. Proponents of term limits probably need to identify better arguments to overcome 230 years of constitutional practice, at least if presidential term limits are any guide. – Federalist Society

The only purpose they really serve is making angry voters think they’re teaching career politicians a lesson. It’s about anger, retribution and petty hatred of the “political class.” And that’s just a holdover from our founding when the country was small and you didn’t need to understand, well, much of anything to be a politician. You could learn it all on the job.

Today, there is simply no way anyone can understand what they’re voting on without years of experience. So term limits are really a vote for the “deep state,” the legacy bureaucracy, who are the only ones then left who know how things actually work.

How? Just. Stop. And get rid of the term limits in place.

3. Implement Ranked-Choice Voting

Without getting into a lot of technical and wonky jargon about voting, most of us can agree that the first-past-the-post 51% voting model that dominates in the USA isn’t ideal. We can’t risk “wasting” a vote on candidates we like, so instead we vote for the candidate most likely to win from the pool of candidates we hate the least. This lesser of two evils model frustrates voters and voter intent, makes it harder for third-parties to win office, and doesn’t even reflect what most voters want. Ranked-choice voting is one of several models that tackle these issues head on:

It’s a little complicated to explain, so here’s an infographic from the Maine Secretary of State, where RCV is already in place. You rank your top candidates and then:

Rank Choice Voting

Ranked Choice Voting – Courtesy of Maine SOS

Several states have already put RCV in place, including Maine in 2020:

To be clear, I’m not saying RC voting is the only option that’s better than the simple majority, just that it’s better. If there’s a preferred or superior option, let’s to that. I don’t care as long as voters can get closer to voting for the politicians they want rather than the ones they hate least. How can that not make America better?

How?  Learn where it’s already implemented and how it improves things. Support or start RCV initiatives in your state. Then, get ready for a better voting experience.

4. Government Use IFRS Accounting Standards (Hard)

I know, accounting. Exciting, right? International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) would require the US government to follow the same rules as pretty much everyone else (or at least, where the world is heading), thus increasing transparency, decreasing software and accounting costs, and paying less to consultants who actually understand our arcane national GAAP and other accounting rules.

This is like the metric system: most of the world uses it, but we don’t. It causes translation cost and confusion. The US uses its own system (US GAAP) instead of IFRS, just like China and a bit of Japan, who also have their own systems. Wouldn’t it be nice if we actually pretended like we were part of the world for a change? That would make America better for, well, everyone.

How? Lots of legal, regulatory and accounting changes. Will it happen any time soon? No. Should we start moving in this direction? Yes. Is this exciting? Sorry, I dozed off. I mean, sure! If you care about government efficiency.

5. Universal Automatic Voter Registration (Hard)

Other than the fact that some parties benefit from low voter registration and turn out, it’s hard to see why we make registering to vote so hard in this country. We’re a representative democracy. Democracy requires voting. Shouldn’t we make that as seamless and efficient as possible?

I’m not going to spend a lot of time explaining this because it’s a contentious partisan issue. The GOP would probably prefer we all give blood and five forms of ID to prove we’re worthy of the vote, and for them, this makes political sense. The more Democrats show up, the worse Republicans perform. That doesn’t make it a sound bases for public policy or elections.

How? Support initiates in your state for motor-voter (DMV-based-registration) and other programs that automate and simplify voter registration.

6. Require Single-Subject Legislation (Medium)

The idea is simple; legislation (bill) should be about one thing, and one thing only, so they are (a) less complex (b) more easily understood (c) don’t carry endless riders and amendments for special interests and (d) aren’t 5,000 pages long. This should be a policy supported by either end of the political spectrum, if not necessarily by political parties that benefit from massive and confusing omnibus legislation.

This has even been proposed as an amendment to the US Constitution:

A federal amendment was proposed as early as 1999 in a law journal article by Brannon Denning and Brooks R. Smith. The Florida Legislature in 2014 passed a memorial applying to Congress to call a convention for this purpose. A bill was introduced in the 113th Congress, and again in the 114th Congress, to propose the amendment by Congressman Tom Marino…” – Wikipedia

If you want to watch the world’s most boring and probably auto-generated summary of this, here’s a video guaranteed to kill some brain cells. Seriously, don’t watch it.

No, wait, this interview with (late) Single Subject Amendment CEO Spider Webb is even more excruciatingly uninteresting.

Despite how painfully uninteresting this topic is, it’s actually pretty important; giant bills full of mysterious amendments are how special interest slip ridiculous things into bills that almost no one even knows are there. And that’s why the single-subject rule is already law in state legislatures, including California:

In California, there is a single‑subject rule for legislation. Found in the state constitution, Article IV, Section 9, it provides, “A statute shall embrace but one subject which shall be expressed in its title. If a statute embraces a subject not expressed in its title, only the part not expressed is void. A statute may not be amended by reference to its title. A section of a statute may not be amended unless the section is re‑enacted as amended.” – CAP Impact

How? Every state could pass single-subject rules as a constitutional amendment, and the same thing would likely be required at the federal level. This will be a challenge given partisan opposition (parties do love their special interest amendments), but if it can get out of Congress and into the ratification process, it’s hard to see how 2/3 of states couldn’t be pressured into passing it.

7. Require an I’ve Read the Legislation Pledge

This is the simple but apparently inconceivable idea that a politician should know what they’re voting on when they…vote on it. There is simply no way that any current politician reads massive 1,000+ page bills pushed at them hours before a floor vote, where they’re just asked to trust party leadership.

The $900 billion pandemic relief package that was rushed through Congress Monday created a familiar year-end conundrum for lawmakers: It was a bill too big to fail, and also too big to read. – USN

What I propose is that a politician’s Yes vote be legally treated like a sworn affidavit stating that they or their staff have read the bill in full, that they understand what they’re voting on, and that pledging ignorance later is a legal admission of fraud. It may sound harsh, but voting for bills you don’t understand because someone told you it was all good is a terrible abnegation of responsibility and common sense.

And one great side effect of this requirement is that the longer the bill is, the longer it has to be publicly available before the vote, which increases transparency and review time. There is already something like this in discussion, though I’d argue this doesn’t go far enough:

The Review Every Act Diligently In Total (READ IT) Act aims to allow members to fully review all legislation before votes. It would institute a new rule in the official House rules, that anything receiving a vote must have been publicly available in electronic form for a number of minutes that’s double the number of pages. – Medium

The proposed Read the Bills Act gets closer to the mark:

The Read the Bills Act (RTBA) is proposed legislation intended to require the United States Congress to read the legislation that it passes. It was originally written in 2006 by Downsize DC, a non-profit organization focused on decreasing the size of the federal government…

Similarly, a separate bill nicknamed the “Read the Bill Act” would require bills to be posted publicly 72 hours prior to consideration in Congress. Unlike the Downsize DC proposal, this bill is supported by ReadTheBill.org (part of the Sunlight Foundation) with the primary aim to increase transparency in government. – Wikipedia

But whatever the name or form of the bill, it’s time politicians were required to read the bills they vote on, and given the time to do so.

How? Pass one of the bills mentioned above, preferably the one advocated by ReadTheBill.org, and then take it a step further to require reading before voting.

8. Stop Infantilizing Adults (Drinking Age 21)

You’re an adult when you’re eighteen. You can be drafted, sent to jail, ruin yourself financially, and so on. You should be able to buy a damn beer. They idea that in the allegedly “freest country on Earth” you can be forced to fight a war oversees and kill people for America but then can’t have a beer when you get back is beyond hypocrisy.

Countries Drinking Age 21

Central Maine Newspapers graphic

All laws restricting the rights of anyone over the age of eighteen should be repealed and are, frankly unconstitutional. The only reason we have this effective national drinking age is because President Reagan imposed it on states by threatening interstate highway funding in 1984.

This video might or might not help inform you about the topic, but either way it’s a good laugh.

So if you want to decrease binge drinking, decrease date rape and sexual assault by drunken idiots, and generally act more like a free country populated by adults, it’s time for the age 21 law to go.

How? Just freaking repeal the 1984 act and replace it with a law that you can’t strip adults of freedom in the name of interstate commerce or funding. Or any other reason short of felony convictions, and then only to the extent necessary.

9. Restore Native American Land where Possible (Hard)

There is no way to undo what has been done to Native Americans in this country, but one problem we can fix is to (at the very least) enforce and comply with land-related agreements that are currently in dispute. See the #LandBack hashtag on Twitter for an active discussion.

Does this mean giving all US land back to all tribes? Of course not. Do I agree with everything being proposed? No. But should we do something to restore lands and dignity where we can, and often where the law requires? Hell, yes.

How? At least start the process of seeing what Native American land can be restored in your region, what remains in dispute, etc. There’s a large learning process here for all of us, and no perfect solution, but it’s time to get started in earnest.

10. Formalize a Default Neutral Pronoun

And I don’t mean “it”. It’s a scary clown or an offensive objectification, not a neuter pronoun. Just pick a set of words we can all use to solve absurd damn problems like calling companies they or who and unknown people he / she or he or she or frack! Why hasn’t anyone just fixed this? And yeah, I know “they” is the current contender, and I’m glad it works for trans people (genuinely), but it’s a grammatical disaster and always has been. We can do better.

Universal Gender Neutral English Standard

Universal Gender Neutral English

One suggestion for a humanist, apolitical and Universal Gender-Neutral English.

How? I guess I’d start with business communications, publishing companies and schools. But honestly, I’m open to ideas.

Other Ways to Make America Better?

I’m sure I’ll have more ideas in the future, but I’d love to hear your thoughts. What works or doesn’t? What’s practical or not? And what do you think we can do to improve America? I mean, the United States.

Peace.

10 Ideas to Make America Better

When people talk about how to make American better these days (meaning the USA), it’s always about the big things–racism, sexism, global warming, and so on. And these things are important, but also hard and complex and frankly disheartening. We sometimes forget that there are many other problems we could solve with relatively simple solutions if we gave them some attention. Things we could do quickly, in other words, if we can just find the will to do so.

That’s the focus of this and possibly future quick-and-dirty posts: What can we do now, today, to make things a little bit better for someone, somewhere, even if it’s not us? These things are not prioritized or ranked (numbering is just a way to order the list), and these ideas are just here for discussion and consideration. What do you think we should tackle first?

Ideas to Make America Better

1. Change to the Metric System (Easy)

What most Americans don’t seem to know is that the US Imperial system is already based on the metric system (via standards set in by ISO in Europe). Most large US companies maintain machinery and systems based on metrics to ensure international compatibility. Food packaging includes both metric and imperial units. We’re already 90% of the way there. So what’s holding us back?

And the answer is, of course, nothing but political will. Neither party has much to gain by pushing the change, no major special interest is driving adoption, so the US is stuck with Liberia and Myanmar as the only countries on Earth not officially using the metric system. And both of the other countries are in the process of changing. We are at risk of “American exceptionalism” becoming American stupidity and irrelevance. This forces US businesses, scientists and pretty one everyone else to maintain two separate measurement systems and convert between them–sometimes causing expensive accidents.

How? Maybe states can start pushing adoption. I’m not sure of federal legal constraints, but there is nothing stopping schools in, say, California from teaching the metric system to ALL students starting immediately, even if it’s just as another option. Start making kilometers the default on road signs. Change all food serving default sizes to 100g like in Europe. Just. Do. Something.

2. Outlaw Political Redistricting (Medium)

Drawing strange political districts to benefit one party is obviously not ideal for democracy, and neither major party theoretically benefits more than the other (although the GOP seems to benefit more in practice). And it would ensure that states elect representatives that are actually representative of the population as a whole.

The key is to remove political parties from the process. Redistricting based on the decennial census should be  focused on creating simple, competitive districts that represent the people of the state, regardless of political party. There are even mathematical systems to help measure how representative a district is:

And there are entire organizations dedicated to these improvements, including represent.us (see video below). We have the tools and knowledge to make these changes now.  What’s stopping us? And the answer is, as always, entrenched political parties the special interests that back them.

And most Americans already support reforms to redistricting to eliminate or reduce political party control.

How? Just freaking demand reform from our elected officials. Call or write your representative. File lawsuits over biased redistricting. Given how polarized the US is, and the increasing speed at which we’re abandoning mainstream political parties, this should be a  non-partisan issue we can actually address.

3. Pay Prisoners Prevailing Minimum Wage (Medium?)

One of the greatest incentives for the private sector to encourage and drive mass incarceration is, the more prisoners they have (a) the more the government pays them and (b) the more cheap labor they have access to. This is in a very real sense a direct legacy of slavery, and it creates an incentive to imprison people. And yes, there’s a Jon Oliver video on this:

Among the MANY reforms needed is to require that prisoners are paid the prevailing minimum wage in their state of incarceration, require that they get to keep their wages, and ensure that the prisons themselves don’t get a single dime of this money. If we want prisoners to fight fires, pay them. If we want prisoners to pick up trash, pay them. Prison is about protecting us from violence and punishing crime, not creating a cheap labor force for corrupt politicians and local factories.

How? Make it a law for all state and federal prisons. Enforce it. That’s it.

4. Make Washington DC a State or Equivalent (Hard)

This one, and the ones that follow on US Territories, probably breaks the rule of being “easy to do” because while it’s theoretically easy, there is no way conservatives in the US will let either happen without a bloody fight. And I can’t blame them — it’s not like DC is going to swing for the GOP anytime soon (see second video, below). And pretending that Democrats are passionate about this for purely humanist reasons is farcical.

But none of that changes the fact that US citizens and legal residents of DC are currently and unfairly deprived of representation in Congress. We allegedly fought a war of independence over taxation without representation, so why is it okay for the people of DC?

In this case, there’s a fight to be had, but it’s a fight we need. The people of DC do not deserve to be treated like second rate citizens.

How? No constitutional amendment is required–this falls under the clear jurisdiction of Congress–and DC must be a state for its people to have the same rights as in other states (are there other creative options?). So GOP opposition just has to be overcome. I don’t know. This is genuinely hard. But we still have to do it.

5. Grant US Territories Statehood or Independence (Hard)

America’s colonial past is an anchor on our democracy, and a travesty for US citizens trapped in a limbo where they’re American but not-quite-American-enough to be treated like full citizens. All American territories should immediately be granted independence or statehood, at their discretion.

The (main) US territories comprise American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, the US Virgin Islands and, of course Puerto Rico.

Every person in all of these territories is currently treated like a second-rate citizen of the US, taxed without representation, abused for land or corporate manipulation, and only partially protected by the US constitution (in practice). This is no way to treat human beings, let alone Americans. These territories should be freed or made states as soon as possible.

How? Great question, and there is no simply answer for the same reason that making DC a state is hard; adding new states affects the political balance in the US House and Senate, and the makes this a partisan issue. And I’d argue that, since most of the impacted people are not English-speaking whites, it’s also an issue for US racists who don’t want brown people to have more power in the country. I’m open to creative solutions? Add more conservative states at the same time by splitting existing states? Something else? How do we solve this problem?

6. Remove All Native Mascots and Team Names (Easy)

This one should be relatively simple, and there’s already vast momentum behind it from the US indigenous population. Native American cultures are not caricatures to be used for mock battle calls or team motivation. The Washington Redskins is a racist name just as the Washington Negroes would be. It’s time to change them, and all it takes is a decision to do so. The costs are not that great. The benefits include showing respect and offering dignity to an oppressed people, so…why not?

Of course there are conservative groups and interests like Prager U that will argue differently, but there is always opposition to change. The response in this case is, so what? This is not a trillion-dollar tax issue. This is not a guns-rights issue. This is just about respecting a people we’ve treated like crap for hundreds of years. That’s it. Everything else is noise and distraction. And we’re already doing it.

How? Just do it. Call your school, representative, team and demand that team names and mascots be changed. There are petitions on change.com. There are campaign websites. This should be a slam dunk.

7. Reform Juries to be More Representative (Medium)

The concept here is incredibly simple. Rather than worrying about the process of jury selection or exclusion, simply make it a federal law that the result of jury selection must be a jury that includes actual peers, or at least one, and is minimally diverse:

  • If the defendant or victim is Black, there must be at least one Black and one non-Black juror, if Asian, then at least one Asian and one non-Asian, etc. In other words, one person must be of the same or similar race, and one person must not be of that race or ethnicity.
  • If the defendant or victim is openly LGBTQ+, then the jury must include at least one person who is also LGBTQ+ and one who is not.
  • If the defendant or victim is disabled, then there must be someone else on the jury with a similar disability, or at least another person with adjacent experience.
  • And there must always be at least man and one woman.

This won’t guarantee a truly representative jury in all cases, but at least it establishes a minimum or representation in all cases.

How? Just make it a law. Or a constitutional amendment. Don’t care. Never again in the United States should anyone face a jury that does not include a simple person that looks like them or understands their experience. And this doesn’t even really have to change the current process. Lawyers can still reject or dismiss jurors they find biased or objectionable, they just have to keep the process going until minimal representation is reached.

8. End the War on Drugs (Medium)

Two of the great travesties of modern America are the vast waste of lives and resources on idiot drug wars, largely to the benefit of US pharmaceutical companies and foreign drug lords, and mass incarceration of young men for petty drug crimes. Both of these issues can be substantially addressed by legalizing pretty much everything and then taxing it.

Legalization gets rid of idiotic legal penalties for personal decisions, raises revenues for treatment, decreases the size of government, and removes one major sources of systems racism from government structure. We’re already doing it with marijuana, and even hallucinogenic mushrooms.  Just do it for freaking everything and focus on treatment.

How? Just freakin’ do it. We live in this weird fear that if a drug is legalized, crazy hippy mobs are going to run rampant in our cities. This is nonsense. Drug treatment and related issues can be easily funded by taxation on those drugs, with none of the costs of an utterly failed and immoral drug war.

9. Default to Roundabouts vs. Stoplights (Easy)

Roundabout Image

Roundabout Image

Hey, not everything has to be about vast and horrible issues. Sometimes you just want to make a little change that makes life better for everyone, and roundabouts are that kind of change. They’re safer than stoplight-regulated intersections, for cars, bikes and pedestrians. They cost less. And they leave space for a cute little garden or statue in the middle.

Roundabout Safety Graph

Roundabout Safety Graph

Roundabouts are already spreading around the country after decades of resistance, so let’s just change the logic: from now on, roundabouts should be the default while stoplight-controlled intersections are the exception you have to justify.

Roundabouts are not a cure-all, of course (see video below), but they are far, far better than traffic-light and stop sign intersections.

How? Anytime the city is building, planning, converting, expanding, just make sure roundabouts are the default and stoplights (or other options) come next, or at least that engineering and planning guidelines include them. This is largely a public education issue. So, tell people roundabouts are awesome. Because they are.

10. Upgrade Affirmative Action (Medium?)

Everyone has a strong opinion on affirmative action, pro or con, racist or not, and it results in more heat and friction than measurable progress. Do middle-class white women benefit more than BIPOC communities? Is it reserve racism? Does it stigmatize minorities on colleges and workplaces? It’s a mess.

There is plenty of controversy around, including backlash against “model Asian” college admissions, and what’s increasingly obvious is that basing admissions on socioeconomic factors rather than race has substantial benefits without all of the controversy:

What I’m suggesting is something a bit more radical: focus affirmative action explicitly on generations of historical poverty. In other words, admissions should favor families and people stuck in grinding poverty for the past, say, ten generations over those that have already made the leap to the middle or upper classes, regardless of race, gender or other factors. Add to this the stipulation the slavery and living on native reservations is by default a state of poverty, and you attain all the major goals of affirmation action without accidentally helping those who are doing just fine without it. I get there are some details to be worked out here, but we can all agree that poverty is bad and getting out of it is hard. So, let’s make it a little easier.

How? Oh, you know, minor political changes and whatnot. But seriously, changing race-based affirmative action to class-based affirmative action preferences is probably the only way to save it in our increasingly divisive political environment.

Other Ways to Make America Better

I’m sure I’ll have more ideas in the future, but I’d love to hear your thoughts. What works or doesn’t? What’s practical or not? And what do you think we can do to improve America? I mean, the United States.

Robert E Lee Statue BLM Protests

Confederate Monuments Need to Go, And You Can Help

The murder of George Floyd by Minneapolis police has forced many of us think harder about how we can help improve the treatment of Blacks in the United States. We have marched with Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests in larger numbers than ever before, and for the first time most white Americans now support the BLM movement and organization. But real change is about more than improved awareness or one-time participation; it’s about long-term, strategic solutions for both the causes and symptoms of systems of systemic racism in the United States.

And Confederate monuments in public spaces remain one of the most pernicious, vile and yet easily addressed signs of anti-black bigotry in our country. It’s time for them all to go, every one, without exception. Some should certainly “go” into museums where we can contemplate their meaning in in the context of slave and racial history. Some of them should “go” to private land if that gets them off of public property. But most should go to a landfill, a crusher, the dustbins of history, buried and forgotten as the shameful relics they are. All of them. Now.

What are Confederate Monuments?

To me, these are not merely statues or plaques. There are monuments of the soul and mind as well of stone and metal, and complete abolition of these monuments requires addressing them everywhere they appear and in all forms. The following list covers most of what I’m aware of, but may not be complete or sufficient; it’s likely just a starting point. But if we really want to do something to help show that Black Lives Matter to us, let’s work to destroy ALL of the following today:

#1 / Belief that the Civil War was NOT about Slavery

Many people believe and are taught that the Civil War was about states’ rights or southern values or some ridiculous collection of niceties that allow White southerners and allied racists to glorify the Confederacy and their precious ancestry without having to acknowledge their hate and bigotry. These beliefs are perpetuated in school books, public schools, physical monuments, state and local laws and throughout the social and legal structure of the American south. It’s time to accelerate the removal and correction of these lies.

#2 / The Confederate Battle Flag

Confederate Battle Flag

Take Down Confederate Battle Flag

As I’ve written before, display of this flag or incorporation of elements of this flag into other symbols (such as state flags) represents an intentional effort to fill the public space with reminders of slavery in the guise of White our Southern pride, and of the ongoing bigotry and hatred of modern racists. It is for all practices the Southern Swastika. Flying this flag is a visual assault on every descendant of slavery, and should not be tolerated by any decent American.

#3 / Public Confederate Monuments

Robert E Lee Statue BLM Protests

REL Statue BLM Protests | WJCT News

These are the most obvious and literal signs of systemic racism in the United States today. You can find statues in parks, plaques in graveyards, murals in schools and far more. All of them pretend to preserve history while glorifying slavery and White supremacy.  If we truly want an egalitarian and post-racial America, every one of them has to be burned, destroyed or otherwise removed from public spaces. Removal of the Robert E. Lee statue shown above is a good start, but it’s just a start.

#4 / Public Civil War Era Names & Mascots

Ole Miss Old Mascot | Black Leadership

Ole Miss Old Mascot | Black Leadership

Numerous schools are already changing names such as “The Rebels” to something that doesn’t glorify and condone the Confederacy, but it’s time for all of these names and mascots to go. The same is true of street signs, park and geographic names–anything in the public domain that glorifies or memorializes the Confederacy’s attempt to destroy the United States and perpetuate slavery.

#5 / Hiding or Denying the Atrocity of Slavery

It may be hard to believe, but there are entire institutions in America teaching that either the Civil War wasn’t about slavery, or slavery wasn’t that bad, or even that slavery was a beneficial institution that helped the poor Black man or woman lead more civilized lives (while of course providing uncompensated labor in the process). Whatever it is, wherever it is, it’s time to burn it all down.

How can you Help Destroy Confederate Monuments?

There’s a lot of work to do here, so to keep from making it seem overwhelming, let’s focus on the physical and publicly visible ones: statues, plaques, mascots and other names. I’m not saying the others aren’t important, but for now, there’s a lot of momentum that can be used to attain specific goals and I’d hate to lose that by diffusing the effort or energy in too many directions.

How to Get Rid of Public Confederate Statues & Plaques

Confederate Monuments | Politico

Confederate Monuments | Politico

Removing any confederate monument will take collaboration, time and money. Some will go easily in the current political environment, but racists will fight for others for years to come. Start with the easy victories and use the momentum to do more, but we’re not done until they’re all gone. Here’s what you can do:

  1. Learn about and help identify monuments near you. Wikipedia maintains a list, but it may not complete. Are there any in your area? Are there any missing that should be added to the list?
  2. Find out who’s trying to remove them. Wikipedia maintains a list of legal efforts and organizations by state. Are any near you? If not, are there any you can support or contribute to? Here are current petitions on Change.org,  but there are many other sites and organizations in the fight.
  3. If there’s no one doing it, do it yourself. Form an organization, start a petition write a blog post. Do something, and you’ll find others who want to help. If you want to feel inspired, here are some of the monuments being removed right now due to the George Floyd protests. Here’s an example of what worked at Ole Miss. You can make a difference.

How to Get Rid of Confederate Names & Mascots

Confederate Street Names

Confederate Street Names USA Map | CityLab

This fight is a little harder, at least in the sense that there are far more names and mascots than statues. There are street names, hills, parks, benches, murals and on and on — hundreds of years of accumulated bigotry that won’t fade overnight.  But just as with monuments, let’s start with the obvious and hopefully more important  battles like school mascots, major street and public names, etc. Here’s what you can do:

  1. Learn about and help identify names & mascots near you. I haven’t yet found  a definitive list of schools, but you can search online for mascots in your state or region. Here for comparison is a list of native-american related school and mascots (which should also go). Here’s a great resources for confederate street names. Have you found better lists or resources?
  2. Find out who’s trying to remove them. The NAACP fights constantly to help remove these names from local schools and mascots, including this recent lawsuit to change the names of Lee-Davis High School and Stonewall Jackson middle schools in Virginia. If there are other organizations in the mix, let me know.
  3. If there’s no one doing it, do it yourself. Start a petition, create a social media page, or just get started by posting something. You’ll find other like-minded allies who want to help. If people like you can get Ole Miss to change their racist mascot, then anything is possible.

Does Removing Confederate Monuments Matter?

Yes! It’s not the elimination of police violence against Blacks, or any number of more life-threatening and economically damaging issues facing African Americans in the USA, but these monuments are a daily reminder of racism and hate. They also help erase the history of slavery and genocide, making future atrocities ever easier.

Imagine if you were a German Jew and you had to attend Goering High School or your team mascot was the Fighting Stormtroopers. Imagine living on Hitler St., Auschwitz Way, or walking by statues of the glorious fallen SS or Gestapo. You might feel just a little bit less welcome in your country. So yes, anything we can do to make America less blind to and supportive of racism, the better.

Black Populations in USA | Politico

Black Populations in USA | Politico

To drive this home, take another look at where Confederate monuments are in the USA, and compare it this Politico map of where Blacks live in our country.  Monuments are concentrated exactly where African Americans live, in their faces, every day, reminding them that they are not yet respected as equals in a nation that allegedly stands for equality.

Thank You

For whatever you do, can do, or will do in the future, thank you for trying. Even if you can just help get one Confederate-glorifying street sign changed, or start one petition to remove a single racist school name, you have made a difference.

Peace.

No Country for Dead Children: It’s Time for Rational Gun Control

No Country for Old Men is a film about the inevitability of evil. No matter what you do, no matter how clever you are, you can’t outrun the devil. The devil in this case is an assassin named Anton Chigurh, and for our purposes he has just captured a rival killer named Carson Wells. Carson knows he’s doomed. Just before he dies, he asks Chigurh, “Do you have any idea how crazy you are?” To which Chigurh responds, “Do you mean the nature of this conversation?”

Carson shakes his head, no, “I mean the nature of you.”

On February 14, 2018, an ex-student walked onto the campus of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkdale, Florida with an AR-15 and shot seventeen students and teachers to death. At least two teachers died defending the children under their protection. As I write this, student survivors like the now famous David Hogg are demanding answers and an explanation. How did we get here? Why didn’t you protect us? How many children have to die before something changes?

The American script is old and tattered. Someone is upset and buys a gun, more likely a lot of guns. They kill people. We express shock and moral indignation. We send thoughts and prayers. The gun lobby is silent, then sympathetic, then indignant. The left is loud, then confused, then silent. News ratings get a bump. Time passes. People die one by one, day after day. Only the body count changes.

“Do you have any idea how crazy you are?” David Hogg might ask us.

“Do you mean the nature of this debate?” America asks.

“I mean the nature of you.”

David doesn’t understand that Sandy Hook is just a remake of Columbine, or that Parkdale is just a remake of Sandy Hook. They are not merely expected scenes in the great American drama to him. His friends died. His teachers died. He knows how crazy we are, and he knows we have to change the script or it will just happen again, and again, and again. But we never change the script. And he knows that too. #NeverAgain is an aspirational name. He’s young. He’ll learn.

Here are the teachers and children who died in Parkland, Florida: Peter Wang, Nicholas Dworet, Aaron Feis, Luke Hoyer, Alaina Petty, Jamie Guttenberg, Alex Schachter, Martin Duque, Alyssa Alhadeff, Helena Ramsay, Scott J. Beigel, Joaquin Oliver, Cara Loughran, Meadow Pollack, Gina Montalto, Chris Hixon and Carmen Marie Schentrup. I have no idea why they’re in that order. Is that the order in which they were shot, died, or were found? It seems entirely random.

NBC News: 16 of the 17 Victims at Marjory Stoneman Douglas HS in Parkland, FL

Whatever order your read or skim their names, these people are not actors. They are not extras, special effects or avatars. They are, or were, someone’s greatest love; the purpose of their life. And now they’re gone, forever. In the sequel, there’s a different cast. And there’s always a sequel.

Next time the devil flips a coin, the child might be yours. Try to imagine that. The bullet from an AR-15 leaves the barrel at more than 3,000 feet per second and has nearly ten times the energy of the average handgun. One apparently random bullet enters your child’s face through the eye socket, liquefies the brain, and then blows off the back of the skull. Was it a boy or girl? Oh, a little girl. What did you call her when she was born? Sweetie? Honey? Doesn’t matter know.

In No Country for Old Men, Chigurh flips an actual coin to decide who lives or dies. It’s not subtle. Sometimes his victims don’t even know what they’re betting. In one scene, he tells a gas station owner, “You need to call it. I can’t call it for you. It wouldn’t be fair.” The owner hesitates and says, “I didn’t put nothin’ up,” to which Chigurh replies, “Yes, you did. You’ve been putting it up your whole life. You just didn’t know it.”

Now think about how you kissed your little girl good-bye that morning. The last morning. Did you pack her a lunch? Did you know what you were putting up? You’ve been putting it up your whole life. This is America. Every day is a flip of the coin. You never thought about how your daughter would die, not graphically. You probably assumed she could have an open casket so everyone could see how beautiful she was. That’s probably not a good idea.

“In 2013, there were 73,505 nonfatal firearm injuries and 33,636 deaths due to injury by firearms,” according to Wikipedia. “These deaths consisted of 11,208 homicides, 21,175 suicides, 505 deaths due to accidental or negligent discharge of a firearm, and 281 deaths due to firearms use with undetermined intent.” People are dying in even greater numbers today. By the time you finish reading this post, at least one American will have committed suicide with a gun or been shot by someone else. Did you know them? Probably not.

No Country for Old Men has one of the most emotionally disappointing endings you can imagine. The hero dies and Chigurh escapes. Evil wins. It’s so inevitable it’s not worth showing on screen. You walk out of the theater feeling cheated. Imagine the missing scene is a Madlib. You can put anything you want into that empty space. You can put the name of the young many who shot 18 people at Marshall HS or the one who slaughtered 9 students and faculty at Umpqua Community College in Oregon. It doesn’t matter. The script is the same, and the ending is the same. Roll credits, find a new cast and start shooting.

Do we understand how crazy we are?

I think we’re starting to. I’m not using cinematic simile to be clever. I’m using it because we have all become involuntary players in a collective act of atrocity. We are used to pretending that what we see on screen has nothing to do with us. It wasn’t our children who died at Parkdale, we did nothing to upset the young man at Columbine, and our legal use of firearms didn’t put AR-15s in the hands of the mentally ill.

All of that is true, and it’s all bullshit. David Hogg’s friends and teachers didn’t die because the devil flipped a coin. They died because you and I did nothing the last time we walked out of the theater. We accepted the script. We allowed it to be remade. We are culpable.

As you stand in the rain at your daughter’s funeral, you think about the words you’re about to speak. You watch the teddy bear on top of her closed coffin soak up water and swell just like her body. It’s hard to remember your speech. If it helps, here’s a template:

“I loved my little girl, _______. She was beautiful and she lit up the room with her laughter. She loved ______ and wanted to be a _______ when she grew up. Everybody loved her. She was innocent. She didn’t deserve this. I just wish I could have protected her. I’m so sorry, baby.”

You should practice in the mirror beforehand. It’s hard to remember the words when all you can think about is how she looked when you identified her at the morgue. She was naked under the sheet on that freezer drawer, and everything smelled like bleach. They tried to clean up her face.

I just wish I could have protected her.

As you stand in the rain, how much would you give to go back in time and protect your little girl? How much would a parent pay for another flip of the coin? A thousand dollars? A million? Would you give your own life instead?

Wouldn’t it be better if we just changed the script? Of course it would. So let’s change it, right now, so neither you nor anyone else has to face that horror again. Let’s start by doing things most of us agree on and most of us want done today anyway, which is some degree of moderate gun control. As you can see from Gallup (or pretty much anywhere you look), there is consistent majority interest in some degree of additional gun control in the USA:

Gallup Poll: Increasing Support for Gun Control

We just haven’t done anything. Why? The answer is obvious: there are powerful groups and wealthy special interests that oppose all gun regulation, and those groups have far more power in US democracy than they should. They think they have the right to direct the story of your life. It’s up to you to take that power back. They’re not going to give it to you.

How do we take that power back? Part of it’s easy; we have to stop believing the story they’re telling us. Gun control is not always government tyranny. You can reduce deaths without stripping Americans of their 2nd Amendment rights. And once we get past the mythology, it’s easier to see the moderate and sane gun control measures that are right in front of us.

Rational & Effective Gun Policy Options

Back in 2017, the New York Times tried to put together a list of exactly those sane and effective gun control policies, in priority order. I know it’s a liberal source, but if there’s a conservative source offering anything  other than No!, I can include that too. I don’t care, as long as the answer isn’t to keep doing nothing.

With that in mind, here is what the NYT came up with. This is a matrix showing popular support along the vertical axis and probable effectiveness along they horizontal axis. Policies closest to the top right are most popular and effective. Effectiveness was evaluated by professional criminologists:

NYT: Where Experts and the Public Agree

Here is the same information presented in tabular format, but including only to the most effective and popular policies (The full list is on the NYT page):

Suggested Policy Effectiveness Public Support
Requiring all sellers to run background checks on anyone who buys a gun. 7.3 86%
Preventing sales of all firearms to people who have been convicted of violent misdemeanors, including domestic assaults. 7.1 83%
Preventing sales of all firearms to people who have been convicted of stalking another person 6.5 85%
Requiring all gun owners to possess a license for their firearm. 6.4 78%
Requiring all sellers to run background checks on anyone who buys ammunition. 6.4 72%
Banning the sale and ownership of all semi-automatic and automatic firearms. 6.1 63%
Preventing sales of all firearms to people who have been reported as dangerous to law enforcement by a mental health provider. 6.0 87%
Requiring all owners to report lost or stolen firearms. 6.0 88%
Banning the sale and ownership of all ammunition magazines with a capacity greater than 10 bullets. 5.8 63%
Requiring that all firearms be recorded in a national registry. 5.7 70%
Expanding screening and treatment for the mentally ill. 5.6 86%

If we begin at the top right of the matrix and work our way down, we should be able to prioritize gun control policies by both effectiveness and probability of implementation.

Gun Policy Options in Priority Order

There is nothing in this list about banning guns or any argument for or against the 2nd Amendment. These are just reasonable, moderate options for regulating gun ownership and purchases while fully supporting the 2nd Amendment, presented in the order of greatest support and probable effectiveness.  I offer them this way because, I hope, we’ll start at the top and work our way down only as necessary–starting with Universal Background Checks.

1. Background Checks for Firearms (& Ammunition) Purchases

According to Wikipedia, a universal background check (UBC) would require that most firearms purchases  in the USA, including those at trade shows, go through the National Instant Criminal Background Check (NICS) system. Wikipedia further notes that: “In a 2017 survey, a panel of 32 scholars of criminology, public health and law rated universal background checks as the most effective policy to prevent gun deaths, ranking it #1 of 29 possible gun-related policies.” This is the same survey referenced in the introduction.

Background checks for firearms is a policy that enjoys wide public support, even among gun owners and NRA members, as shown in this 2018 Washington Post article. There is slightly less support for the same checks for ammo purchases.

Capital Insight: Support for Background Checks

What I’m suggesting is a policy that requires UBCs for both firearms and ammunition, and that sales are banned to specific groups of people:

  • People who have been convicted of violent felonies or misdemeanors, including domestic assaults until they are a reasonable number of years past serving all prison and probation time;
  • People who have been convicted of stalking until they are a reasonable number of years past serving all prison and probation time;
  • Anyone under a current restraining order for domestic abuse;
  • People who have been reported as dangerous to law enforcement by a mental health provider, with a clear definitions of what types of mental illness applies, and for how long.

With the exception of restraining orders, this corresponds exactly to the most effective and popular policies in the NYT poll of criminologists (shown in green):

Background Checks and Rejection Criteria

Note: I don’t support a firearm purchase ban for anyone suspected of anything, including domestic abuse, terrorism, etc. This has to be done with full due process, or it’s an overreach.

Some states have already enacted similar legislation, including Connecticut, which went much further by:

…expanding an existing ban on the sale of assault weapons, prohibiting the sale of magazines with more than 10 rounds and requiring the registration of existing assault rifles and higher-capacity magazines. The state also required background checks for all firearms sales and created a registry of weapons offenders, including those accused of illegally possessing a firearm.  – New York Times

I ‘m not advocating for or against what Connecticut has done. My only comment is that if you are concerned with excessive limitations on your 2nd Amendment rights, supporting a Universal Background Check is one way to take a gradual approach that may prevent states from doing much more on their own. Burying your head in the sand is not going to work. Being part of the solution just might.

WILL BACKground CHEcks HELP?

Yes. This one policy change, requiring purchases for both firearms and ammunition to go through a reasonable, instant background check, should have minimal impact on law-abiding citizens while reducing the incidences of gun violence. If any single policy change should be enacted ASAP, this is the one.

In fact, according to a study in The Lancet, the combination of firearm and ammunition background checks are two of the most demonstrably beneficial firearm regulations:

After adjustment for relevant covariates, the three state laws most strongly associated with reduced overall firearm mortality were universal background checks for firearm purchase, ammunition background checks, and identification requirement for firearms.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Universal Background Checks for firearm purchases, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Universal Background Checks for all gun and ammo purchases, whether made in retail stores or at trade shows and other venues.

For too long, criminals and the mentally ill have been able to purchase firearms without consistent background checks. American citizens are dying by the tens of thousands. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

Additional Thoughts

The only real intellectual opposition to this is from conservatives who claim that background checks will lead to a giant government database that can later be used to restrict the rights of Americans. I cannot emphasize how archaic this argument is. Do you honestly think the government doesn’t already have this database?

We allow them to collect just about everything for security reasons via numerous NSA and other programs. This includes email, phone numbers, contacts, associates and god knows what else. There’s your list. They have it. You’re on it. If you support NSA surveillance of electronic communications, then you  already support the existence of a list of Americans. And if you don’t, who cares? It already exists.

In other words, there is no rational fear of the government creating a list that it already has. The only list it does not have is a firearm registry, and the creation of that list is not recommended here as a policy suggestion (see below); it is of dubious value, and will never pass at the national level. There is no reason irrational fear should get in the way of a universal background check process.

Given that there is no net additional threat to American liberty posed by universal background checks, I fully support them as national policy. I hope you do too.

2. Outlaw Modifications to Create Automatic Weapons

This isn’t on the NYT list, because it’s already supposed to be the law. Automatic weapons and machine guns are already illegal. Bump stocks such as those used in Las Vegas are just a technical way to get around the law. Close the loophole and enforce it.

WILL THIS BAN HELP?

Probably. It’s a little hard to know, because bump stocks and other equivalent modifications are so easy to make yourself. Black market kits are easily obtained. It’s worth doing for the simple reason that a bump stock serves no practical defensive or hunting purpose; you can’t aim worth a damn when firing with one.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support a Ban on Bump Stocks, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Banning Bump Stocks and all Conversions kits and methods that result in Automatic Firearms or the equivalent.

There is no reason for anyone to have an automatic weapons. They are not used in self-defense or hunting. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

3. Require Firearm Licenses (& Training?)

According to the (liberal) Giffords Law Center, “We require a license for many activities, such as driving, fishing, and working as a teacher, but most states do not require a license to purchase or possess a gun. Licensing laws help ensure that gun owners exercise their Second Amendment rights legally, safely, and responsibly by requiring them to get a license before buying a firearm… Licenses may only be issued or renewed after the applicant has undergone a background check, completed a safety training course, and passed written and performance-based tests showing that the applicant knows relevant gun laws and how to safely load, fire, and store a gun.”

There are of course many ways to define firearm license requirements, though most incorporate Universal Background Checks or the equivalent. As you can see from the chart below, criminologists rate licenses as effective, and they are also popular with the public, but related safety training requirements are seen as far less effective. Given the difference in expert support, I would strongly support gun license regulation even if it omits the safety requirement, so that at least a basic license can be enacted nationally.

Gun Licenses (& Training?)

WILL Gun LIcenses and training HELP?

Probably. However, I’m a big fan of evidence. Most of what I see online is based on correlation to gun crimes rather than causation. What about a license reduces firearm violence, and how does it work? What is the best type of license? I have no problem with a basic, affordable, non-bureaucratic license to start, but we should also invest the time and money to figure out what works best and modify regulations accordingly.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Gun Licenses & Training, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for requiring Firearm Licenses and Reasonable Safety Training.

Anyone with a firearm should have at least the common sense licensing that you have with, say, driving a car. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

4. Require Reporting of Lost or Stolen Firearms

This is one of the most highly effective policies, according to criminologists, and enjoys relatively high popular support.

WILL Reporting lost or stolen weapons HELP?

Yes. This is largely an effort to better understand how guns are getting into the hands of criminals. If owners are held responsible for their weapons, it’s harder to accidentally let them fall into the hands of people who would fail to pass the Universal Background Check.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Requiring Owners to Report Lost or Stolen Firearms, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Requiring that Owners report Lost or Stolen Firearms.

There is no reason for anyone to allow firearms to fall into the hands of criminals, or otherwise bypass fair background checks. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

5. Increase Mental Illness Treatment & Funding

This is one of the few policies that seems to have conservative support, largely because it has no impact on the Second Amendment. There is still a debate about whether mental illness actually correlates to gun violence, with advocates for the mentally ill asserting vehemently that no such correlation exists. On the other side, there is research such as that done by the LA Times:

According to our research, at least 59% of the 185 public mass shootings that took place in the United States from 1900 through 2017 were carried out by people who had either been diagnosed with a mental disorder or demonstrated signs of serious mental illness prior to the attack…

Mother Jones found a similarly high rate of potential mental health problems among perpetrators of mass shootings — 61% — when the magazine examined 62 cases in 2012.

Whatever you believe, there can be little doubt that there is benefit to keeping firearms out of the hands of the mentally ill (if only to help reduce suicide rates). And given that both sides seem to agree on keeping guns out of the hands of the mentally ill, there’s no reason not to try and see if it works.

Mental Illness Treatment

WILL MENTAL ILLNEss SCREENING & SUPPORT HELP?

Probably, but only in conjunction with Universal Background Checks. It will also require substantial funding to be fully successful, making it one of the most expensive options on this list. It’s important, I support it, but I’m dubious that we as a nation will adequately fund anything at this point. So, would it help if done right? Sure. Will it ever happen? I doubt it. It feels like a distraction.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Mental Illness Treatment & Funding, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Mental Illness Treatment for and Adequate Funding in order to help decrease firearm violence.

There is no reason for our country to ignore the needs of the mentally ill until it’s too late. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

6. Consider a 3-Day Waiting Period?

This is a policy that is probably effective, but which has relatively weak popular support. I would strongly suggest that legislators not allow inclusion of a waiting period get in the way of passing, say, more popular Background Check laws and regulations.

Waiting Periods

WILL Waiting periods HELP?

Yes, but more for suicides than, say, mass shootings. A Harvard University discussed in Science Magazine found demonstrable benefits of waiting periods when implemented at the state level:

When the researchers analyzed the data, they found a sharp 17% drop-off in gun homicides and a 6% reduction in suicides when those states had waiting-period laws, they report today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Waiting Periods for Firearm Purchases, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Waiting Reasonable Waiting Periods for Firearm Purchases in order to help decrease firearm violence and suicides.

There is no reason for our country to allow people to die needlessly, and in the heat of the moment, if a simple cooling off period could save lives. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

7. Consider a High-Capacity Magazine Ban?

According to Wikipedia, “A high-capacity magazine ban is a law which bans or otherwise restricts detachable firearm magazines that can hold more than a certain number of rounds of ammunition. For example, in the US, the now-expired Federal Assault Weapons Ban of 1994 included limits regarding magazines that could hold more than ten rounds.” This a popular policy among liberals, but criminologists don’t appear convinced that it’s very effective.

High-Capacity Magazines Ban

WILL Magazine Size LIMits HELP?

Maybe, but only with mass shootings, and only to the extent that reloading and/or carrying multiple clips slows the shooter down. This is one where we should try it and see if it makes a difference; if not, it’s easy enough to undo.

Any such policy should be tracked to ensure that it is implemented in a way that maximizes chances for success and minimizes impacts on law-abiding citizens.

Want MorE INformation?

There are many resources online, all with their own biases. Please take the time to learn what all sides have to say before making your decision.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you support Limiting Firearm Magazine Size to Less Than 10, contact your Senator, Representative and your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full support for Banning  High-Capacity Firearm Magazines.

There is no legal reason for larger magazines, which make it too easy to kill multiple people in mass shootings. Something has to change.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take the death of innocent children.

Please pass appropriate legislation and/or regulations TODAY.

Thank you.

8. DO NOT Create a National Gun Registry

I’m not going to go into the reasons why right now. This is a policy that is of dubious benefit and will cause massive backlash. Let’s focus on doing what we can to protect our children and families.

9. DO NOT Overreach on Regulations

All political groups tend to overreach when they have power. And there is always a backlash proportional to that overreach. I’m not saying take it slow. I’m saying take it gradually. Start with policies we know will work (and can pass), like background checks, and evaluate the impact. Get all parties on the same side. Otherwise, we’ll still be having this argument 100 years from now, children will still be dying, and that sounds awful.

10. DO NOT ARM TEACHERS (!)

This is so crazy I don’t even know how to describe it without sounding crazy. You want to give the same public officials and teachers you (the right) hate, degrade, dismiss and de-fund to be given access to federally funded firearms and firearms training? You want public schools full of socialist teachers and libtards to be heavily armed, give them access to government-managed stockpiles of weapons, and just hope they decide not to shoot you with them?  It’s almost like you don’t care about liberty as much as you care about gun manufacturer profits. That’s just crazy, right?

If you really mean that we should fortify schools, hire security guards, buy metal detectors and turn our schools over to the TSA, I assume you’re ready to spend millions more on public education? I didn’t think so.

WILL ARMING TEACHER HELP?

 No! Back away from the crazy. Here’s a great article on how, if you arm teachers, they’ll probably just end up shooting their own students. Maybe that’s what the NRA wants? Fewer future liberals. Genius.

Why not Take Action Today?

If you oppose Arming Teachers, contact your US Senator, Representative AND your state legislators today. Here’s a letter you can copy-paste into an email or contact form:

Hello:

I’m writing to express my full opposition to Arming Teachers in public or private schools.

As you know, public school employees are government employees, and we don’t need the government to have any more firearms.

While I know you have many constituents, if you think my vote counts, you’ll take this letter as seriously as I take this threat to my freedom.

Please DO NOT pass legislation and/or regulations to arm school teachers. Ever.

Thank you.

Other Suggestions?

The previous suggestions are just that; policy options that have been vetted and discussed for years, but only suggestions. Do you have better ideas? Do you think there are other things we can do to protect our fellow Americans from gun violence while protecting gun owner rights? What are your ideas? Bring it.

Pending

Contacting Your Representative

Whatever your viewpoint, it doesn’t matter unless our legislators and politicians hear from you. They’re working of a script written by lobbyists and special interest groups. Wouldn’t you rather they listen to you?

You Can Change the Script (And Save Lives)

When the old Sheriff in No Country for Old Men tasked with hunting down Chigurh talks with his predecessor, he gets no sympathy. “What you got ain’t nothin’ new,” he says from his wheelchair. “This country’s hard on people. You can’t stop what’s coming. It ain’t all waiting on you. That’s vanity.” It sounds like wisdom, but it’s just surrender.

America is no longer a country for old men. Students like David Hogg are finally standing up and demanding that we do something. They don’t accept that evil is inevitable. They don’t accept that life should be lived on the edge of a coin. They don’t ever want you to stand in the rain at a funeral and choke out your daughter’s name one last time before you bury her in the dirt.

Why do you?

Peace.

Incumbent Handicapping is Better than Term Limits

If there is one thing Americans agree on these days, it’s that politicians are terrible. In the latest polls the US congressional disapproval rating continue to hover between 70% and 80%, making it slightly less popular than President Trump and only marginally more popular than North Korea and syphilis. Which can make it hard to remember that this is a democracy and our House of Representatives is meant to be the “People’s House”. Which people, I wonder?

The natural reaction to things that we hate is to get rid of them. We swat mosquitoes, stomp on cockroaches, irradiate cancer and, of course, we can do the same to politicians by voting them out of office. Except, of course, that we don’t. The only thing we do more than rail against Congress is reelect congressional incumbents (at a rate of rate of 90% or more). This is often excused by saying that people like their politicians, but hate everyone else’s, or that it’s easier to hate an institution than a person and so on.


I’m not going to delve too deeply into this apparent contradiction. Let’s just assume that people really wish government would work better, and that the legislature should be doing a better job. I do not believe this entirely — there are groups and people who undeniably benefit from government dysfunction and dysphoria — but most of us are probably genuine in our frustration with government and our desire to improve it.

And what we’ve been taught, what has been beaten into us, is that political incumbency is bad. If there’s a problem with government, we should just “Throw the bums out.” And if we’re not throwing the bums out on our own, maybe we need a little help. Maybe, in fact, we need to automatically kick the bums out after a certain number of terms.

If this seems like a pedantic way to get to the concept of term limits, that is not an accident. Term limits are not a natural and obvious problem to government dysfunction. No one that I can find sat down and looked at the pros and cons of incumbency, ideal turnover rates, congressional responsiveness, and proved that term limits would actually solve any real problem. Rather, we hate Congress and thus we want Congress to go away. Somehow, if we just force electoral churn, the government will just fix itself.

This is despite the fact that the concept of term limits is logically absurd in almost any other context. We don’t throw business leaders out if they’re doing a good job just because an arbitrary amount of time has passed. We don’t toss out good doctors with bad, great restaurants with terrible or great friends with abusive jerks.

But with government we have internalized the assumption that government is dysfunctional and corrupt, and thus excused ourselves of any responsibility for making it better. Enter term limits as an automated system that allegedly protects us from the corruption that inevitably comes with holding office for too long. Power corrupts, after all, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Isn’t that the congressional tagline?

To understand why this is problematic, it’s important to understand a little about the history of voter rights in the USA.

Voting Rights Cannot be Taken for Granted

Well, they can be, but they shouldn’t be. There is a short page on Wikipedia for the timeline of voter rights that goes into more detail than I can, and a far longer one on the general concept of voting rights in the USA. Take a moment to skim these pages, if you like. Now, welcome back to our regular scheduled polemic.

If I were feeling more emotional, I’d say term limits are acts of cowardice and sloth. That would probably seem a bit harsh, but if there is one thing you can demonstrably prove is that a lot of people have spent a lot of energy (and blood, and lives) fighting for the right to vote. Non-land owning whites fought for it, and won. Women fought for it, and won. Minorities fought for it, and won. I guess that was too much winning, so now it’s time to capitulate. We really appreciated the rights, but you know, it’s just too much responsibility.

Let’s take a more rational approach. It is of course important to realize that voter rights are vital for democracy and cannot be taken for granted. Here, for instance, is a short list of major voting rights milestones in our country, taken from the previously mentioned article and keeping in mind that having the legal right is not the same thing as being able to exercise it in practice:

  • 1789 / The US Constitution gives states the right to set voting requirements, which are generally limited to property-owning or tax-paying white males.
  • 1792-1838 / Free black males lose the right to vote in several Northern states.
  • 1870 / The Fifteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantees the vote to non-white men and freed slaves. Yes, it took an amendment to the constitution.
  • 1920 / Women are guaranteed the right to vote by the Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
  • 1924 / Native Americans get the right to vote.
  • 1943 / Chinese immigrants get the right to vote.
  • 1961 / Residents of Washington, D.C. get to vote for President.
  • 1965 / Protection of voter registration and voting for racial minorities.
  • 1971: Adults aged 18 and 21 are granted the right to vote by the Twenty-sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
  • 2013 / Supreme Court ruled in a 5-4 decision that Section 4(b) of the Voting Rights Act is unconstitutional.

Whether you agree that any or all of the above represents the form of Democracy that you believe in, you have to admit two things. First, that progress on voter rights does not follow some inevitable arc toward unencumbered universal enfranchisement; there is movement forward, and then setbacks. Second, that people have fought pretty hard for your right to vote. American citizens have marched, rioted, been arrested and died for it. You do not have the right to take it for granted.

Civil Rights demonstrator attacked by a police dog in Birmingham on May 3, 1963

And yet term limits represent an undeniable abnegation of these hard-won voter rights. It cannot be more simple. You currently have the right to vote for anyone eligible to run for office. Term limits make all politicians ineligible to run for office after a certain number of terms. Term limits make it impossible for you to vote for politicians you might otherwise have voted for, and thus strip you of your rights as a voter. To repeat:

  • People fought and died for your right to vote.
  • Term limits take this right away.
  • Therefore, term limits are a slap in the face of the soldiers, veterans and other Americans who fought for that right.

Term limits ought to be unconstitutional; the fact that they have not been wholly eliminated by the Supreme Court just means that we do not appreciate how easily such rights can be lost.

To make the point more emotionally: Here is a flag. Now burn it. That’s term limits. I’m astonished by how many so-called conservatives will blow up the internet to save a symbol of liberty and freedom, and then use the resulting ash to choke-out the electoral system from which all meaningful liberty derives.

Term Limits Do Not Work

Even if term limits were not a frontal assault on voter rights, they simply do not work. Which is to say, they work perfectly if your purpose is to make government run less efficiently, give lobbyists more power, and undermine the legislative branch of our government. If you want the opposite of those things, term limits are a truly terrible idea.

I know what you’ve heard. Term limits make politicians less likely to be captured by special interests, and keeps them from staying in office long enough to make themselves rich on corruption and graft. This is utter and complete bullocks. Yes, I’m swearing in a foreign dialect. That’s how upsetting this is.

It’s vital to understand that politicians are captured by special interests the second they run. Political campaigns are insanely expensive and resource intensive. The average person simply cannot run at the city, state or national level without taking money from some special interest group. And almost none of them can win without the endorsement of a major party and its interest groups (business, churches and police for conservatives, unions and trial lawyers for liberals). So they’ve sold their souls long before they worried about reelection. Knowing that they’re going to get kicked out office and have to run for some other office (e.g., House of Representatives followed by the Senate) just means they are even less focused on doing their job and need even more money and more allies more often. This is almost the definition of corruption, and term limits don’t fix it; they make it worse.

Term limits also have the same problems as almost all over-reactions to actual problems, which are massive unintended consequences. These include having people in office who have no freaking idea how it is to run a government (think of it as a large business run by people who have no idea how to run a business). And just when they learn how, you fire them. Brilliant.

I know, you’re thinking, they’ve been corrupted. They have to be purged. It’s like sin, but with ballot boxes. I’m not even going to argue the point. I’m just going to say that, if you actually wanted government to run well, you would elect people who know how to run government. Every time Americans vote for term limits, they’re voting against America, because America is a democracy, and democracy is a form of government. If you don’t want your government run well, you don’t want democracy to work. So why are you reading this?

Imagine you run a business. Imagine it’s the largest business in the history of the world, which makes it pretty hard to manage. It needs help. You have a board of advisers and they seem like a smart group of people who made some mistakes. So you get a new board and some fresh blood. Great! Off to work. Let’s put together a plan to–

Stop!

We just fired your board. Here’s another board.

Okay, damn, let me try to get this business going. Does anybody here remember how this things works? Well, let me explain it to you. See, we build widg–

Stop!

We just fired your board. Here’s another board.

Oh, screw this. This board sucks. I’m just going to outsource to a bunch of consultants the stakeholders can’t fire. I mean, sure, they’re called lobbyists and they have no interest in running the business except to bleed it for their own venal cause, but it’s better than having to teach these child-like board members how not to drool on themselves.

Stop!

Your business is bankrupt. You’re fired. Everyone’s fired. Well done.

That is how term limits work, except we don’t seem to care. We’d rather be self-righteous, angry and slap some congressmen than actually solve real problems. Which I suppose is a nice way of saying that we are part of the problem. We think government is just the ridiculous crap that vultures do when they’re not stripping flesh off the dead. What we don’t seem to understand is that government is just a service. We can have much or as little of that service as we want, collectively, but no matter what its size it’s better if it runs well. Term limits make that impossible.

Don’t get me wrong. I understand that a large group of Americans have a vested interest in making it run poorly. When conservatives say they want to make government small enough to “drown it in the bathtub“, the last thing they want is a well-run government program — because that makes it harder to hate and then kill. It is no coincidence that these are some of the same people that advocate for term limits; they want government to be dysfunctional and, to the extent it still functions, that function should be to serve them and they’re special interests. This article is not for these people.

If, on the other hand, you truly want government to run well no matter what its size (and whether you’re liberal or conservative), then you might want to take a look at states where term limits are in place to see if they actually make things better. California has had legislative term limits thanks to Proposition 140 since 1990. It’s not better. So I have to ask the conservatives reading this; you hate California so much you want to leave or cut it in half, but you want to make the rest of America more like California? Really?

Sarcasm aside, there is absolutely no evidence that term limits make government run better or make politicians more responsive to voters. So endeth the rant. The rest of this is for Americans who actually care about America, and I hope that’s most of us.

Fact One: We are a democracy, or a democratic republic. The important point is that we manage our government with our vote. That is our only offensive power as citizens. Everything else, including the Second Amendment, is defense.

Fact Two: Democracy has challenges, including the excessive and always growing power of incumbents. It’s not just the franking privilege (Yes, I am that old), it’s all the power you gather around you, the name recognition, the deals and, yes, the corruption. All of it means that we probably do not have nearly enough turnover in in Congress as a result of voting, because we love incumbents when they are our incumbents. Love them.

Fact Three: Term Limits seem to work pretty well at the executive level. Why? Because executives acquire the power of incumbency the fastest, and are a lot like CEOs. They don’t have to know the details of how to run a government; they hire people that do, nudge the ship in one direction or another, and then someone else comes along. Most of the real daily work is done by the bureaucracy, which doesn’t turn over that much, and Congress, which is supposed to know how to legislate and regulate in order to drive the bureaucracy.

Term limits at the executive level just mean a new boss every four years, same as the old boss. Term limits at the legislative level means firing everyone who knows how stuff works. It’s like a software company firing all of its software developers. Sure, the CEO can talk pretty for a while, but then you get a problem with an application, and someone has to fix it, and…the lobbyists are the only ones left. This is one reason why lobbying groups such as the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) are successful; writing good legislation is hard. Letting lobbyists do it for you is easy and, in fact, the only choice if you have no idea how to do it yourself. This effect of term limits are one reason why ALEC advocates term limits; it gives them more power. It gives corporations more power. And you, well, less.

Fact Four: We are part of the problem with government. We still think we’re in high school and the best people to elect are the ones we partied with. Hint: They are morons. Well, not all of them, but a lot. The ones you really want in government are the kids whose names you can’t even remember because they’re too busy actually getting stuff to work. Think of that kid who as the treasurer. We need that kid in Congress. We need a Congress full of genuine, hard-working, normal and yes boring dudes and dudettes who have absolutely no interest in ever being Prom King — or Prom King or, at least, know they never will be. But you keep voting for Prom King and wondering why he gets drunk and drives the car off the bridge.

If you actually want government to work, you should think of it like your car. You want an engine that works. It just works, You won’t want a Porsche to show what a douchebag you are to other countries. You don’t want a Jaguar that breaks down all the time (yeah, yeah, I know). You don’t want a Bugatti because, well, taxes. You don’t want a Yugo because…do I really have to explain this? You want a Camry. You want an Accord. You want whatever American car is like a Subaru. You want a car that gets good gas mileage and never, ever breaks down and bores the crud out of you, so you simply don’t pay attention anymore. That’s good government; it’s not exciting, but it doesn’t get you killed or drain your bank account.

When was the last time you voted for that car? Yeah, never. You vote for the Ferrari or the Zombie Apocalypse Hummer or the Commie Citroen every time. That’s on you. You need to fix that. Otherwise, it doesn’t matter what we do. If you keep voting for the truck that’s best at crushing the other guy’s sporty coup in the congressional demolition derby, you’re just going to get broken government. Maybe that’s what you want. I hope not.

But, enough about cars. We’re here to talk about term limits. So let’s assume again that you want better government and are concerned that incumbency is a problem and you want do something reasonable that addresses the problem without blowing up the neighborhood. Do you have any better ideas?

Fact Five: I have a better idea. Amazing, right? And you thought you’d just come here for the outrage.

Incumbent Handicapping is a Better Idea

I know what you’re thinking. Upset with your incumbent politician? Just take an ax to them. If that won’t motivate them, nothing will. Genius. But, that’s not the kind of handicapping I had in mind. Plus, it’s gross and may be illegal in some states.

Here’s how it works. Instead of term limits, incumbent handicapping addresses the unfair reelection power of incumbency by making it harder to get elected, but not impossible. Incumbent Handicapping (IC) does this by adding an increasing percentage of the total vote required for reelection of the incumbent with each subsequent election cycle up to a reasonable cap.

Let’s take the two-year terms of the House of Representatives as an example. In the simplest case, IC might mean that the incumbent has to get 52% of the vote to win the second election, 54% to win the third, and so on, up to a cap of 60%. This means that you can always vote for the congressperson you want, but they have to really work to stay in office. I should note that this only really works for popular votes. For the Presidency and the Electoral College, it may have to remain term limits as it is today.

The point is, with IC, at no point are you prevented from voting for whomever you like. Your candidate can always run. And as long as he or she remains popular enough to beat the spread, they can stay there forever. It’s just hard, and they have to work for it. They have to earn your vote…and they will.

Incumbent Handicapping can be applied at every level of government and simply had to be adjusted to find the right percentage handicap per term and the right cap so that it doesn’t become the same as term limits.

How do we figure out the right cap on the spread? Great question. I imagine that some very exciting mathematical modeling by district size, election type, mid-term vs. general election, etc. can give us a number or two that represent the percentage Incumbency Advantage (IA). We’ll call it the Incumbency Advantage (IA) because, well, everyone else does. For the sake of argument, let’s say the IA% is typically less than 10%.

Vanderbilt 2015: The Incumbency Advantage (IA) has grown but remains below 10%

You might think 10% is an under-estimate. According to Open Secrets, House races in 2016 saw a fun-raising gap of $230k vs. $1,600k for challengers versus incumbents, which is truly staggering; however, it’s also misleading. This represents highly partisan fund-raising in highly largely gerrymandered districts, which just means that fund-raising between different party candidates is a poor proxy for an IA% between the same parties. In other words, the IC is meant to balance out an incumbent running against an equally qualified challenger in the same party, not to fix imbalances in partisan fundraising or those caused by partisan redistricting.

I realize this is a bit dry, but hey, it’s politics. Remember that boring car we’re trying to build? Well, it’s not all coke parties and naked skydiving on the assembly line. Deal with it.

Rather than add too much math to this discussion, let’s imagine that in all House Races the IA% is 10% and in all Senate races it’s 12%. And you want the IA% gap to be closed within ten or twelve years respectively. This would mean that Representative incumbents would have to win with 2%, 4%, 6%, 8% and then finally 10% more of the vote than the nearest challenger. Senate incumbents would have to win by an additional 6% and then 12%. If you want people to turn over faster, you just adjust the dial a bit and viola, less incumbency. And of course you can go the other way as well, making it easier to stay in office but not that easy. Remember, the point here is to balance out the real Incumbency Advantage to make elections more fair, not to shove people out just because they’be been there for a while.

If done carefully, Incumbent Handicapping takes care of the long-term incumbency problem while simultaneously making it possible to keep the great, dedicated people who keep our Ford Focus running. IH keeps Americans from being stripped of the right to vote for any candidate they like. And IH actually disempowers lobbyists, because good people can keep their jobs long enough to get good at it.

I realize there are far greater issues with governance, but at least this makes things a little better. And doesn’t break the wheel. Term limits break things. IH doesn’t.

In Summary:

  • Term limits are bad.
    They don’t work, and the violate voter rights.
  • Incumbent handicapping is good.
    Like all ideas, it should of course be tested and proven.
  • Think about it.
    Please.

So the next time someone screams about term limits, let’s talk calmly about Incumbency Handicapping instead. It’s not as exciting, sure, but it might actually work.

Peace.

Related Resources

What, you’ve got more time on your hands? I can take care of that…

Discussion Points
  • Is Incumbent Handicapping constitutional?
    Yeah, no idea. Sure. I think it would depend how it was applied, and which party sued and which part controls the Supreme Court when they do.
  • When should IH take effect?
    IH could be introduced any time after the incumbent’s first election, but given that this is meant to be an alternative to term limits, it could be delayed to start at the same time term limits would otherwise have started. That way, it doesn’t impact the first few terms, and only matters when you want to throw the bums out anyway. Credit to JM for this idea.
Measuring the Incumbent Advantage

So many PDFs, so few pretty pictures. Bur if you’re in for a good soporific read, here is some background on attempts to calculate the Incumbent Advantage (IA) and why it’s grown over time.

Anti Term Limits

I’m always a little saddened when things that should be non-partisan resolve along party lines. But it seems pretty clear that term limits as a concept are largely advocated by conservative groups and denounced by liberal ones. If you find conservative sources here, I’ll be glad to include them.

However, I’ve come to believe that term limits are an intentional, cynical effort to weaken the power of the legislative branch relative to the executive branch, and hence the power of “people” versus aristocrats and business. This tends to align with some policies of the Republican party, but I do not believe it represents a truly conservative worldview.

Pro Term Limits

See all notes under “Anti” (above) and reverse them.

Polling on Term Limits
Disclaimer?

As far as I can tell, this whole Incumbent Handicapping (IH) idea is mine, but I know it can’t be. Someone must have thought of it before. Love to see some evidence of it. The same basic concept came up last year, but it was applied to US presidential elections, which is the one place it won’t really work, so I’m not counting that.

My guess is it has a different name, and I just haven’t found it yet. Most “Alternatives to Term Limits” appear to be term limits with gaps. So, for now, I’m taking credit. I’d actually be glad if someone proved me wrong.

Puerto Ricans are Americans & They Need Our Help

Let me be a little blunt. I’m not trying to be rude, but sometimes it helps to just be candid about things.

I don’t care if you like President Trump or not; that is not the point of this post, and nothing I say here will change anyone’s opinion one way or the other. There is a tracking poll on 538 that tells me pretty much all we really know; Trump is not popular, but he never has been. He was not elected by popular vote; he was elected by the electoral college. He was elected, and he is our President, whether you like it or not. He took the oath of office, in which he said:

“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my Ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.”

That has literally nothing to do with this post; I just thought there was something in there about protecting and defending the American people. I guess not. Moving on.

I also don’t care if you think Puerto Rico is getting enough aid or not, because you don’t really know any better than I do and arguing in the absence of facts is what politicians are for. I’m sure we all have better things to do with our time. At some point someone will do a study of reaction times and resource delivery comparing Katrina, Harvey, Irma and Maria. Democrats will celebrate. Republicans will cry foul. Whatever.

My question now is the same as this has been since Maria struck Puerto Rico, and that is, why don’t we seem to give a damn at any level that this tragedy has struck American citizens? At least, not to the same extent we did for Harvey in Texas and Irma in Florida?

This, again, has nothing to do with Trump or whether aid is being effectively delivered or not. I’m just going to assume that FEMA, the US Navy, and other organizations within our government are doing their best with our without guidance from the Commander-in-Chief. There are some really great people in these departments, and I wish them all the best. Puerto Rico needs it.

My question is why we just don’t seem to care about PR the same way we did about Texas and Florida. I noticed this before the storm even struck. There wasn’t the same amount of coverage. There wasn’t the same media frenzy. There were these oddly calm news commentaries and then, well, I don’t know. What did I miss?

It turns out, not much, or rather, my perception was correct; there just wasn’t the same amount of coverage or interest. Here is a Google Trends comparison of searches for the three recent hurricanes by name:

And here is the same chart by where the hurricane struck:

Notice anything? Comparatively few people searched for information about Maria or Puerto Rico even after the political nonsense with Trump and Twitter and the PR Mayor. Why?

Were we just burned out on hurricanes? Was everyone focused on Kneel Gate? Or, did we just have no idea that PR was part of the United States? Turns out, the last answer may be among the best. As first reported by the New York Times, almost 50% of Americans don’t know that Puerto Ricans are US citizens.

When poll respondents were asked about support for PR aid, they were twice as likely to be in favor if they were aware that Puerto Ricans are, in fact, Americans:

So, perhaps, our lack of interest is due to the fact that our educational system sucks. It’s possible, even likely. I’m going to assume, again, that this has not impacted government action or even Trump’s role in the response. It has, however, clearly impacted people’s inclination to help the people of Puerto Rico:

I hope that’s all it is. I hope it’s not that most Puerto Ricans are albedo challenged and we’re not just being racist jerks. It would even be better if we just cared about states more than protectorates. But if we assume that there is either racism nor statism involved, we’re left with a bit of mystery. Given the recent spat between Trump and the major of San Juan, it would seem unlikely that Americans who care to know still remain ignorant of PR citizenship. In fact, many of them have actively sought to answer this very question:

Notice that searches for information about the hurricane in Puerto Rico are almost the same as searches for “Are Puerto Ricans American?” Hopefully, when they realize they are just like us, the inclination to give will rise to Houston levels, because the need is far greater. But I doubt it.

Why?

Let’s get back to Trump and his argument with Mayor Carmen Yulín Cruz. Even the National Review believes that this engagement has been counter-productive politically. Again, I don’t care what you think about Trump or the mayor or who’s right. What I do care about is whether the behavior of our President in this context has made it less likely for Americans to give financially in support or Puerto Rico.

I don’t know the answer, not with any certainty. If you look at the trend above, you’ll notice that interest in giving declines very roughly as the PR Mayor searches increase. But this is a weak correlation at best. What I suspect, based on what I’ve seen on the news and social media (anecdotally), is that the dispute has not helped. Some people will go without because the President is arguing with a Mayor on Twitter regardless of who started it or who is right.

This is at best a lost opportunity. What I would hope, what I would expect, is that a President of the United States would care more about the Americans in PR than the Mayor of San Juan, and would brush aside the dispute. That he would take a scan second few seconds this unique moment in history to explain to those who have missed it that Puerto Ricans are Americans and those Americans will need  our help long after the Navy and FEMA have left. But he has not. And he will not. So it’s up to us, Democrat or Republican, to fill the gap.

That is perhaps a long way to get to the point. It is not that I am disappointed in how Trump has handled his dispute with the mayor, although I am. The point is that no matter how you feel about this, you should still care about the people of Puerto Rico and want to help them. So, if you can, here are just a few places where you can make a contribution.

Every little bit helps. And goes a long way to proving that we don’t care about Puerto Rican skin color or language, that we do not play politics with American lives, and that the people of Puerto Rico can depend on the United States just like any other part of this great country.

Plus, it’s tax deductible.

Thank you.

Peace.

Washington Redskins / Is it Cultural Appropriation?

The NFL Washington Redskins name & mascot — Are they cultural appropriation?

Yes, but more importantly, who cares? The primary issue here is not cultural appropriation, it’s racism. Imagine, if you will, a set of possible NFL team names and slogans:

  1. The Washington Darkies
  2. The Washington Slant Eyes
  3. The Washington Redskins
  4. The Washington Crackers
  5. Any Other Damn Name

If you were part of a focus group, and at least one of your criteria in picking a team name is that it shouldn’t racially denigrate an entire group of people, you would pick #5 every time. Admit it. Even though crackers are delicious, they get soggy when they sweat.

Of course, there is the argument that when the name was chosen, this type of racism was either not recognized or collectively ignored. Maybe the team owners genuinely in their hearts-of-hearts thought the name was a celebration of the Native Americans’ fighting spirit. Maybe everyone thought it was just the bees knees.

But none of that matters. Today, in the actual world we now live in, the Washington Redskins is very obviously and undeniably a racist name. And I say that knowing full well that people are denying the crap out of it. Even Native Americans:

Which just means we’re all human and, like all humans, we can be wrong. Because this name and mascot are wrong. They just are. People may disagree, and be truly passionate and sincere about that disagreement, but that doesn’t change the common sense nature of this problem. You don’t get to call teams by the skin colors of “other” races. Not anymore. Not ever again. Get over it.

So what should we do?

Change the name, of course. Almost anything would be better. Maybe the Washington Concussions or the Chiropractic Wet Dreams? At least those would be accurate. If you really need help here, I’ve got lots of ideas. Some of them involve small mammals and nipple clamps, sure, but that doesn’t mean they’re not just as valid. They’re certainly less offensive.

Just change the name, please.

Because sometimes you just do things to be respectful, kind and make the world a slightly better place. Sure, it’ll cost some money and, sure, it’ll  mean some traditions have to change, but it’s the name of an NFL team. That’s all it is.

And if you change it, the team can market their cultural awareness and sensitivity while selling new schwag and raking in even more money. Local Native Americans can focus protecting their culture(s) for the next generation. And the people of Washington DC can turn their attention to other things like, well I’m not sure what, but I’m sure there’s something other than football that needs some attention in DC. I hear it’s moist in Puerto Rico.

(Change the name!)

Peace.

Attribution: The idea for this post is taken from a truly offensive set of Tosh.0 skits called “Is it Racist?” but he probably appropriated the idea from someone else.

Respecting the Stars & Stripes

The last time I checked, this is the flag of the United States. The Star Spangled Banner. The Stars and Stripes. Old Glory. The one and the only flag of the United States to which we pledge allegiance, period:

I pledge allegiance to the Flag
Of the United States of America
And to the Republic for which it stands
One Nation under God, indivisible
With liberty and justice for all

I say this because today the internet lost its mind in a massive flame war between the NFL knee-takers (KTs) and the anti-knee-takers (AKTs). I don’t really have much to add to that particular debate; everything that can be said has been said, and many things that shouldn’t have were probably said as well.

But what I will take note of is the key argument of the AKTs–which is is that KTs are traitors and hypocrites because they are disrespecting the flag that represents the sacrifices our soldiers-in-arms have made over the centuries to protect the people and institutions of the this great country.

Again, I don’t really have much to say about this perspective and I will admit to understanding it even if I don’t fully agree. I tend to think the argument is a cynical way to distract from the true issues at hand, but let’s assume for argument’s sake that the AKTs are sincere and that they truly believe that this flag, this one Star Spangled Banner is being trampled, metaphorically, by the KTs.

Then I’m going to have to assume that the AKTs also believe that anyone who flies a different flag, a separate flag, a flag representing a nation that tried to destroy the USA, is also a traitor and hypocrite and should love our country or leave it. Especially if that flag cost the lives of 640,000 US soldiers — more than any other US war or conflict. Well, here is that flag:

This is the Confederate Battle Flag. The flag flown by many American southerners and the KKK and pretty much anyone else who thinks this alternative flag, the flag flown during battles that killed or injured nearly a million loyal Americans, is better than the Stars and Stripes.

So I have no problem with the viewpoint espoused by AKTs that we should respect the one and only flag of the United States of America. As long as they actually, consistently and clearly do that.

Because if you support flying, showing, praising or in any way respecting this other flag of slavery and racial aggression, than you do not respect the Stars and Stripes or the people who died defending it. You have to pick one, and I’d suggest you pick the actual flag of the actual country you claim to love.

With that in mind, I’m just going to assume that every AKT screaming about the horrors of protesting in a way that spits metaphorically in the face of our armed forces is also simultaneously supporting the eradication of this symbol of confederate terrorism for the exact same noble reasons.

I thank you for that act of moral and intellectual consistency, and appreciate your help in my effort to eradicate the southern swastika.

Peace.

Confederate Battle Flag

Confederate Battle Flag is the Southern Swastika

The fact that the Confederate battle flag (CBF) is flying above the US Flag (or at all) in South Carolina in this century is simply absurd. It really doesn’t matter if you feel worked up about the injustice of the War of Northern Oppression and how it was only partially about slavery. It doesn’t matter if you, justifiably, think that there should be a distinct and glorious symbol that recognizes the true sacrifice of Confederate soldiers during that war. All that matters, and I can’t say this clearly enough, is that you believe in the United States of America. Because if you do, we have no need or place for a southern Swastika.

And we already have a flag for this county; it represents UNITY and the common interests of all men and women of all colors in this nation. The only remaining purpose of the Confederate battle flag is to intentionally perpetuate hostility between states, people and cultures in a nation that has more than enough problems already — that, and to slap every African American in the face every single time they see that obscenity flying anywhere.

Let’s take a walk down the sweet, sweet road of reductio ad absurdum (not a Harry Potter reference) and the inevitable Nazi swastika comparison. The swastika was once a proud symbol of “auspiciousness” in eastern religions until it was coopted by Hitler to stand for the rising power of the Third Reich. Most Americans and the world in general saw it flying during the 1936 “Nazi” Summer Olympics and thought little of it. Yep, the Germans had a bad time of it after WWI and overwhelming burden of reparations. Good on them on pulling themselves up by their bootstraps and adopting such proud and jaunty iconography as their own. What was a little Jewish persecution compared with progress?

Leap forward over the smoking bodies of 13 million exterminated Jews, Gypsies and other human detritus, and the German swastika was no longer associated with its prior meaning—it was, is, and always shall be the symbol of the holocaust. Whatever earlier meaning it may have had, however many German soldiers died proudly in trenches serving their nation and not the Nazi party, it doesn’t matter; the German swastika is a symbol of evil, an affront to every living person of Jewish descent, and an important reminder of the true lunacy and depravity of which our species is capable. If the German swastika is preserved at all, it should not be on a flag, but only in textbooks to help us remember the true cost of racial hatred.

Likewise, the Confederate flag was once perhaps a symbol of something other than white supremacist bigotry. It may have stood for all things proud and wonderful in southern history. It may have meant something unbelievably wonderful, but quite frankly, no one in their right minds gives a damn. The Confederate battle flag is stained indelibly with the blood, anguish and genocide of slavery. It is forever imbued with the stench of human atrocity, collective racial sadism and the willful dehumanization of human beings based on their skin tone. We should preserve the CBF, not as a symbol of southern heritage, but as yet another reminder that human beings are capable of being unmitigated assholes (See “swastika”).

There a fairly famous phrase about a “more perfect Union” in the Preamble to the US Constitution that is key to everything we hold dear today, and also everything represented by the Stars & Stripes (you know, the other flag). Under the Articles of Confederation, the US colonies were incredibly weak. The reason we were able to realize the genius of our Constitution was very simple; without it, we were going to be torn apart by Britain and other foreign powers and reduced to little more than feeble, obsequious colonies on the Atlantic coast of the new world. We chose unity to survive, and I can’t emphasize how strongly these terms are related.

We face enormous, absurd, almost insurmountable challenges as a nation today. The rise of foreign economic powers, the burgeoning menace of organized global terrorism, strains posed by our staggering population on the collective resources of the world, and far more. We have only survived as a nation this long because we have come together when threatened. We came together to bind a nation as one under the Constitution, to fight the spread of German expansionism in two world wars, and again to oppose the tyranny of the USSR and global socialism. We came together to celebrate the space program, cure polio and so much more. We came together because unity is survival.

So when I see the Confederate battle flag, I see it for what it is; an affront to every living being who has ever faced sadism at the hands of another, and a threat to the very unity of this country. Because make no mistake—when a southerner waves the CBF, he or she does it not to prove they are part of the US, but to show that they are separate from it, above it, and unanswerable to the moral framework of the Constitution. They are giving the Stars and Stripes, and you, the finger. And that pisses me off.

If you’re awake, it should make you apoplectic with rage. But hey, maybe it only really affects those poor black people over there in that neighborhood you never drive through. I mean, come on, Game of Thrones is on.

So why get off your ass and do anything about it? We haven’t done it yet. Maybe we never will. Maybe our “more perfect Union” was an inside joke by white guys in the 18th Century. But I don’t believe that; I can’t. There is a certain amount of Kool-Aid you have to drink to believe in anything anymore, and this is Kool-Aid I drink willingly. We are a challenged nation, a flawed nation, but there is greatness in us and that greatness comes from unity. We just to remind ourselves of that.

We’re Americans, damn it (with all the pride and shame that comes with it). We’ve interned people in internment camps, and that was pretty messed up, but we also rebuilt Germany after WWII and put men on the moon with less computer power than you’ll find in your Fitbit. We invented the internet, pants and deep-fried everything. Are you seriously telling me that you have so little faith in this nation that the only way to raise yourself up is to tear someone else down? What if it’s not a zero sum game? What if supply-side morality actually works and a rising tide raises all races? Isn’t it at least worth a chance to put hatred away and try something else for just a little while?

I’m too old to know how to really make social media work. I think if I posted this with a picture of a kitten hugging a chicken quoting Rodney King I’d get a billion likes and Pulitzer. Fortunately, I’m also too old to care.

Here’s a hashtag: “#FuckTheSouthernSwastika.” Better yet, here’s an idea; just take down the damn flag, say you’re sorry, and let’s figure out how to help our fellow Americans lead better lives.

Related Stuff

Jon Oliver on the Confederacy

Peace.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén